I prefer to start sending messages via LinkedIn InMail to pass spam filters. That's their main advantage. Another positive thing about LinkedIn is adding context: the recipient is aware that the distance between him and you is short.
When I get a proper email directly to my inbox, it immediately gets my attention and it's likely to get a reply.
BUT, the messages I send try to be laser focused and I have a good success rate of conversions (~20%)
If I get a direct email that is definitely not based on a template means that that person a) found my mail and b) spent some time on the process, so I usually reply as courtesy.
I applaud your approach, although I think it's difficult to get noticed in a noisy channel and LinkedIn messages are overused.