Map: These are the cities that climate change will hit first
washingtonpost.com
washingtonpost.com
Direct link: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v502/n7470/pdf/nature12...
From the methods summary section:
They used the projections of seven climate variables: near-surface air temperature, sea surface temperature, precipitation, evaporation, transpiration, surface sensible heat flux, and ocean surface pH.
"For each model and variable, we used the period 1860-2005 from the historical experiment (the longest time span common to all models), to establish the historical bounds of climate variability. The projections...[were used] to simulate the period 2006-2100...to identify the year at which mean annual values of a given variable would exceed historical bounds."
"In total, for all variables and experiments, we processed 89,712 years of data comprising 1,076,544 monthly global maps, interpolated to an equal-area grid with a resolution of 100 km."
I think the 9 in 1960-2005 must be a typo. Everything is 1860 in the study.
[0]http://www.economist.com/news/science-and-technology/2157446...
Because there is a huge-ass economy hidden under 'green' politics and without the drama nobody would vote for governments that impose penalties on people using old equipment. Haven't you noticed that most 'fixes' on climate rely on buying new shit (German automotive market as the easiest example) and favor developped economies over the troubled ones?
We can't forecast the position of a molecule of gas in a balloon more than a tiny fraction of a second out, but that doesn't mean you can't predict that the temperature of that gas will increase when you compress the balloon.
> A city hits "climate departure" when the average temperature of its coolest year from then on is projected to be warmer than the average temperature of its hottest year between 1960 and 2005.
It's a gradual change that is already happening, and there's plenty of other side-effects of climate change that will be notable long before this artificially defined tipping point is reached.
Because you turn away people. I'm a conservationist that just happens to think regardless of climate change that it just makes sense to preserve finite resources like fossil fuels and clean air. When you start to use bullshit to further our similar cause, then you hurt our cause when the bullshit is exposed.
I actually saw the headline and excitedly clicked on it. I was excited because with all the talk of climate change I feel like I never see anything other than abstract predictions of "x degree C raise in global temperature". I thought FINALLY tell me when coastal regions of New Jersey are going to be permanently underwater. No such luck - more abstract bullshit masquerading as something it's not. You have no idea how much this hurts people's belief in climate issues.
Plus, something tells me that this episode has not truly shaken your belief in climate change :-) If this paper leads a few thousand skeptics to finally embrace science, I view that as a win.
Ahem: "An integrated encyclopedia of DNA elements in the human genome" [1], published in Nature (they published in Science too but I don't have the cite handy) -- masterfully demolished [2] by Graur et al.
You might say that the ENCODE paper's authors "are guilty of framing their results in the most arresting manner possible". You might also say, inflammatory as it would probably be, that their results are "bullshit"; Graur et al. certainly seem to have taken that view, if not in such earthy fashion, and they did an excellent job of demonstrating in exhaustive detail exactly why that's so. (If you're at all familiar with the ENCODE work, but haven't read "On the Immortality of Television Sets", I strongly recommend you do so -- and that goes double if you've seen the reams of garbage in the popular science press about "the death of junk DNA".)
Climate science, of course, is a much more generally contentious field than bioinformatics, and much political power attaches to it; one does not, after all, often find governments writing policy on the basis of a bioinformatics consortium's latest recommendations, while such behavior is the status quo in climate science. Were that otherwise, one wonders whether Graur and his co-authors would've found themselves unable to publish in GB&E or any recognized journal, and had to resort to doing so on a website of their own. Perhaps they could name it "Genomics Audit".
As for laymen such as myself, a mere software engineer without a day's worth of tertiary education to his name, well -- all I can say is that, while evaluating the evidence for and against AGW (climate change, whatever) and developing an informed opinion of any sort requires enormous intelligence and domain knowledge, spotting propaganda does not, and neither does mistrusting propaganda once spotted.
Your comment here verges upon an argument that propaganda is only evil when unvirtuously engaged in; that is, that the ends justify the means. I suggest that fallacy inheres within this line of reasoning, and that even a superficial review of the history of the 20th century suffices as demonstration. Perhaps you disagree.
[1] http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v489/n7414/full/nature1...
[2] http://gbe.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2013/02/20/gbe.e...
Bits of shadiness that have pushed me away:
- When I started reading papers on climate simulation (I was also solving wave equations numerically), I started seeing wildly unjustified assumptions in climate modelling papers. In spite of the obvious flaws, the models are portrayed as highly accurate rather than merely the best than can be done on current hardware [1]. This reduced my confidence by a bit.
- Odd claims about the validity of the models. GCM models + economic analysis suggests that the cheapest method of mitigating climate change is geoengineering (specifically, using human engineered pinatubo-style forcings). Yet geoengineering is dismissed as wildly unpredictable. Either GCM is an effective model, or it's not. If not, we have no counterfactual to compare to the historical record.
- Climategate. That's not how science is done. Yet rather than cleaning house, double checking everything and forcing the perpetrators out in disgrace, everyone rallied around them. That feels more like politics than science.
This paper is just using models and getting headlines. It's not a big deal. But throwing nonsense at people in an effort to get them to accept your claims is a bad idea, particularly when the primary argument is an argument from authority.
[1] Making unrealistic assumptions and doing the best you can is just a part of science. I object only to portraying toy models as the real world.
I wonder if this is what it was like in the mid-1900s when the science for the dangers of tobacco was starting to really solidify and the tobacco companies were running full-bore to discredit it.
Those who have reasonable, scientific grounds for being skeptical of anthropomorphic climate change (and there are people smarter than you or I in that boat) don't like the shrill, political-based "deniers" much. They do, however, think it's good to scientifically examine the assumptions of papers such as the one that came out in Nature today. Climate modeling is quite hard, and the conclusions climate scientists come to are open to skeptical investigation.
It's certainly become a weirder field of study since politics became its main audience.
This thread isn't full of those people - it's full of shrill deniers.
I welcome skepticism. But what people call "skepticism" in the climate debate is nearly always blind contrarianism.
Your post is a great example of this type of trash. You start off comparing one of the most researched fields, involving decades of effort spread amongst thousands of researchers around the world with a small number of people who did not even have an understanding of the mechanisms (genetics, embryology, etc) with which they were dealing. The GP's analogy works quite well, our certainty of cigarettes causing lunch cancer is about the same as the IPCC's certainty of anthropomorphic climate change.
Second, apart from the normal peer-review of specific papers, there have been several large-scale attempts to "review" all of climate change. A great example is the "Climategate" fiasco, which after a review by a sceptic funded the oil industry, turned out to have been nothing but an attempted hit job on the scientists involved.
Third, there is actual review and revision going on within the IPCC. One of the major differences between the 2007 and 2014 IPCC reports is the narrowing of the predicted temperature ranges. Deniers however don't seem to have the evidence to work within the normal scientific process, so instead they must engage of various types of deception and PR work to get their points across.
So no, it certainly has not become a weirder field of study. It's just that people threatened by facts are trying to apply political tactics to a non-political field, much like creationist attempts to revise or silence evolution.
Really? You do realize that word is usually used in the phrase "holocaust deniers" and was purposely appropriated by AGW followers to discredit anyone that doesn't subscribe their beliefs.
Now that is propaganda at its finest.
They may not do it for everything, but the same person who's "skeptical" of climate change is also likely to be "skeptical" of the link between HIV and AIDS and of the health risks of tobacco. Beyond this, I've seen it cover everything from the health risks of bad diets to the safety benefits of seat belts and air bags in cars to the source of underground petroleum to whether evolution is true.
And no, I'm not doing one of those things where I treat the opinions of a large group of people as a single block. I've seen all of the above in a single person.
There is some kind of strange mental switch flipped in some people that somehow makes weird contrarian theories attractive.
What's inappropriate about the word? Godwin struck awfully quickly with you, but OK, let's go with the Holocaust comparison. While denying the Holocaust is bad, it doesn't directly kill people very much. On the other hand, if climate change deniers have their way, it may result in a calamity that will kill vastly more people than died in the Holocaust.
http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2006/sep/19/ethicalli...
Somebody bookmark this so that we can refer back to it in 2025, when the same model predicts the same thing to start happening in 2040.
As a reasonable thinking person, I see no reason not to expect that to happen again some day.
The possibility of another ice age scares me much more than any effects from AGW.
Here's what the US and Canada looked like 20,000 years ago: http://faculty.ccc.edu/jtassin/geology201/homework/Chicagoge...
For example, highlighted in the article: Washington DC's 2069 climate if we do nothing will be the same as Washington DC's 2071 climate if we 'substantially bring down carbon dioxide emissions'.
According to the article this result is "significantly mitigat[ing] the effects of climate change".
The expenditure that moves that date 2 years is going to be astronomical. I WANT to be convinced that these measures make sense, but so far it all seems very flaky (not climate change - what we're doing about it).
This is a clever bit of public manipulation because who can argue against the fact that climate is changing....
What is not agreed, is the degree of change, its manifestation and the effect, if any, that Man is having on said climate change.
The reason for talking about climate change is not the technical one but just the sales pitch: For the past 15 years or so, the predicted warming did not occur, so a memo went out to talk about climate change.
Heck temperature, or average global temperature, should be easy to report, just degrees F, C, or K. Still, the usual evidence was in terms of the snows of Kilimanjaro, icebergs crashing into the sea at the ends of glaciers, and pictures of polar bears, pictures of ice in the Arctic during the summers, exploitation of the fact that due to winds and currents where the Arctic ice collects varies from year to year.
BTW all those people talking about the warming of the Arctic didn't report from first hand data during the winters, right, with maybe -80 F and 80 MPH winds. A reason for that? I know: Lots of reporters tried but just didn't come back!
If can pull off the warming scam using mostly just pictures of polar bears, etc. without talking about temperature, then for climate change, where the evidence is much more difficult to analyze for significant changes or trends, can be talking about absolutely nothing for centuries until finally the scam shuts down the first world economies, which is one of the goals.
Or as one global warming scientist admitted, a major benefit is the collection of beneficial social changes. He had in mind that from the cooling from shutting down the Industrial Revolution teenagers on dates would have to wear lots of extra clothing and, thus, make it more likely the girl would still be a virgin when she got married???
It's a scam, guys. The science is just window dressing. Don't be gullible. It's essentially the same as the threat of a pool table in town in the movie The Music Man where the real goal was to get money and take the next train out of town.
Did I mention, it's a scam? You believe that Al Guru is interested in the science? What about Tom Friedman: On a late night TV show he said that the threat of CO2 is that it absorbed sunlight. Wrong, Tom. If CO2 absorbed visible light, then we could see the CO2 as we exhaled. Instead, the issue of CO2 is that it absorbs in three narrow frequency bands, one for each of twisting, bending, and stretching of the molecule, out in the infrared, and the main source of the infrared in question is not directly from the sun but just the black (gray) body radiation of the surface of the earth warmed by absorbing the visible and UV radiation from the sun. I know, Tom, in freshman physics you were out on the quad arguing that the earth was flat.
Why do the NYT and WaPo keep flogging this old horse? To have stories easy to write, for years, and get ad revenue. They have heavily just created the story so that they can write about it.
Other fellow travelers in this scam include business people who want Federal Government money and politicians who, then, want kick backs, excuse me, campaign donations.
Did I mention, it's a scam?
Where you go completely into tinfoil hat idiocy is when you call revising a label to fit data "public manipulation". It's just good science.
Take a bunch of measurements and formulas and curve fit it into a computer model. Ignore any inputs that cause outliers and keep on adjusting the weightings and inputs until what you perceive is the correct "result" is obtained.
This is not science.
The Koch brothers told you that tens of thousands of scientists around the world are making up a devious plan to... to what? to get you to use CFL bulbs?... and you believe the brothers. Great.
Make sense now?
This explains the behaviors of BOTH sides of the debate.
AGW is a religion, pure and simple. We are all sinners (producers of CO2), scientist are priests, believers point to their scriptures, non-believers are considered heretics when they point to how illogical the belief is, and it all ends with Armageddon.
Regardless of where you fall on the scientific spectrum of accepting the conclusions being drawn from the evidence, or where you fall on the spectrum of proposed political changes (if any), that's just basic logic and reasoning.
Found via the Nature article. More data, less hype.
Well, which is it, 1960-2005 or 1860-2005?
Right: WaPo is continuing to flog this old horse, trying to keep it going as a long list of stories easy to write for nearly automatic eyeballs and easy ad revenue.
/s
(For those who don't get it: http://www.skepticalscience.com/ivar-giaever-nobel-physicist...)
This stops being a scientific problem when it becomes a political one. I'm not going to let someone tell me what I can and can't do just because they have a PhD and a model that proclaims doom.
Neither is say high-speed aerodynamics. We can't predict where a particular air molecule will go in a turbulent flow. We have only approximate closed-form models, and do most work in simulation and by fitting empirical data to simplified approximate equations and tweeking constants until things come out right. Yet airplanes still fly and people don't get on the internet armchair talking about how Boeing's aerodynamicists are wrong.
> This stops being a scientific problem when it becomes a political one. I'm not going to let someone tell me what I can and can't do just because they have a PhD and a model that proclaims doom.
Deniers live in a world where people can tell them what they can and cannot do.[1] Deniers know this, so they attack the scientific conclusions because they know that the public will, quite rationally,[2] tell them what you can and cannot do if they believe there is even a substantial chance that the climate scientists are correct.
[1] That's the quid pro quo isn't it? The public tells big strong guys that they can't go around killing and eating people, and consequently reserves the right to tell other people what they can and cannot do.
[2] It is of course eminently rational to take even very expensive corrective action in the face of a low probability but extremely high cost negative scenario.