Selectively setting the bar ridiculously high can be an indicator of bias. I find the practice intellectually dishonest.
Selectively setting the bar ridiculously high can be an indicator of bias. I find the practice intellectually dishonest.
Actually it's an indicator of skepticism and intellectual honesty, exactly what any scientist should have... As Feynman would say, a "kind of leaning over backwards" to show how you might be incorrect.
All quality scientific theories are validated when we have empirical or mathematical proof that demonstrates that a given X process produces Y results and evidence. For example, an explosion of a bomb (X) results in a certain pattern of destruction (Y). We know that upon seeing a certain pattern of destruction (Y) we can infer that it was a bomb explosion because we've seen and witnessed prior explosions (X).
The only way the existence of (Y) can logically infer the existence of (X) is if we've previously tested and validated that X indeed produces Y.
Is it so much to ask that I have X process demonstrated before I truly believe the theoretical assertation that Y evidence really indicates the existence of X process?
Is that not what real science is about, forming theories and then empirically validating whether or not X indeed produces Y as we claim is does?
In physics we have equations like E=mc^2 which are constantly tested and validated. In chemistry we have repeated and empirically validated experiments that show how adding a catalyst to a reaction will speed it up. In biology we have demonstrated and visible results of how different types of light affect plant growth. In electronics we repeatedly validate that V indeed equals I times R. And the list goes on...
Don't you get it? X process is repeatedly tested and validated to produce Y results. That's how quality science works.
I don't care if you have a whole mountain of what you claim is Y "evidence", if you can't repeatedly demonstrate and validate the assertion that X process produces Y results then it doesn't matter how much "evidence" there is, there is no true logical basis to claim that Y infers an X until you have demonstrated X->Y.
Pardon my skepticism.
But if you want experimental results concerning evolution: http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn16382-artificial-molec...
Moreover, efforts to create more life in the labs will eventually hit a philosophical wall, not a technical one. "If somebody makes something great in the lab, it's fantastic. But really the origin of life on Earth is an historical problem that we're never going to be able to witness and verify," he says.
Well at least we know that the planet's magnetic field is produced by aligned iron molecules in the core since... Well shit, I guess we can't fit a planetary core in the lab.
Ok, I've got one: we know that the sun is a nuclear furnace, fusing hydrogen into helium because... um...
Well, I guess you're right. We can't know anything by repeated inference.
I sure hope the sun comes up tomorrow.
Edit: Shit, mine look worse. Retrieve palm, insert face.
Let us hope that you are troll sir, for otherwise we must conclude that you are an idiot.
Here, let me link you to Science 101 so I can help your tiny brain understand this: http://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/0_0_0/howscienceworks_07
See that little formula?
Idea + Expectations + Observations = Scientific Argument
1. We have the scientific idea - Macro evolution over 4+ bn years
2. We have the expectations (aka what you call circumstantial "evidence") - fossil record and a whole mountain of other expectations.
3. So where exactly are the observations that confirm this idea produces our expectations? Nowhere. You can't observe Macro evolution in action. All that exists is a mountain of circumstantial expectations with no observations.
Two-thirds of a scientific argument doesn't equal a scientific argument, moron. It certainly must seem like trolling when you don't even understand the process by which scientific arguments are validated.
Look, the reason I didn't link any more observations of "macro" evolution is because examples have already been linked (and you've ignored them), and because you seem to think that you have logical grounds for dismissing all evidence while clearly demonstrating that you do not understand either basic logic or the scientific method. Seriously, google "modus moron" and fix your shit if you don't want to come across like an ignorant creationist troll.
I suspect that your real complaint isn't based on anything that is clearly evident from what you have posted so far and that pointing you at stuff you could easily find for yourself if you were genuinely curious is a waste of time. But in case I'm wrong:
http://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/CB/CB901.html http://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/CB/CB910.html http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/speciation.html
I don't know why Evolutionist trolls continue to insist that ID advocates "toss out all the evidence".
You are aware that the same "evidence" such as the vast fossil record, and insane complexity of the universe is what forms the basis for the ID argument, right? Even Dawkins himself admits that all intuition indicates that the universe has been designed.
I'm not tossing out any evidence, I'm re-interpreting it under my own world-view, in the same fashion that you have your own self validating world-view where you interpret the "evidence".
Regardless, explain to me how forensic science and circumstantial evidence works if my "shit" above regarding the bomb example is not sound. It's not a truth table that I've written above, it's an assertion that we can guess with high probability what event happened if 1) we have seen the event in the past or can replicate it and 2) we understand the effects and resulting evidence for that event.