If I am to spend my tax money on those in need, I do not want more than half of it going to upper middle class bureaucrats and middle class administrators.
If I am to spend my tax money on those in need, I do not want more than half of it going to upper middle class bureaucrats and middle class administrators.
Far too many abuses are allowed to go on simply because of such arguments thereby reducing the aid we could give to truly needed people.
I am all for helping those in need, nearly 2% of my gross salary goes to CHOA each year, but damn if I am going to believe that there are people on one if not more of the hundred of government programs who don't deserve to be there. The best way to help people is to get more diligent about policing those we do help. Are they getting the right help is the question that we must answer.
If your win condition is "eliminate most of the cheaters", I'd like some proof that we're not already at the Nash Equilibrium for that with the current system.
Would the cost of doing that exceed the savings? If so (and that seems rather likely; the vast majority of social welfare recipients do _not_ cheat), it seems rather impractical.
In practice, people cheat in all systems, and a certain amount of cheating is built into the assumptions for any well-designed system. For instance, tax authorities do not audit everybody, because it would be impractical; in not doing so they accept a certain amount of tax fraud. Shops don't watch everyone who comes in the door all the time, because it would be impractical; in not doing so they accept a certain amount of theft (most of what accountants call 'shrinkage' is employee and customer theft).
(On a side note, a "large bag of cocaine" sounds like a business investment, investing in the highest return commodity available to the investor... not that I condone it, but it is somewhat different from what I assume you intended, namely buying recreational drugs for personal use rather than providing for one's children).
So, I was really just wondering if you've ever had any first or second-hand indication that your assertion isn't just bullshit.
Christian Parenti really sums it up well when he describes American views on poverty in his book, The Soft Cage:
"In a society that denies the true causes of poverty—low wages and structural unemployment—the poor necessarily show up as objects of mystery to be examined, measured, interrogated, and indexed, or as James C. Scott would put it, made “legible.” In a society that hides the real mechanics of exploitation and sees all social phenomena through the lens of individualism, it is assumed that the poor—their genetics, their habits, or their culture—must be the true cause of poverty."[1]
Specifically with respect to your point about drugs:
"Reports such as the National Survey of Drug Use and Health suggest drug abuse among welfare recipients is hardly widespread. Many states have tried drug testing for welfare recipients with practically nobody testing positive. In Arizona, for example, in 2012, after three years and 87,000 screenings, one person had failed a drug test. Utah's drug screening program spent $30,000 on testing and only 2.5% of recipients turned out positive for illicit drugs. Florida's program had the same results.
"In all cases, the testing -- which assumes all welfare recipients are druggies -- cost much more than the savings in welfare payments."[2]
We need to stop acting paternalistically toward the poor and, instead, treat them as people who are capable of making their own decisions.
[1] http://openlibrary.org/books/OL7593829M/The_Soft_Cage
[2] http://www.cnn.com/2013/09/30/opinion/granderson-michigan-we...
http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2011.pdf
Your source [2] also disagrees with you. When Florida implemented drug testing, they spent $46k to identify 108 drug users (presumably taking them off the welfare rolls). Unless welfare costs less than $425/person, that's a net savings. Further, according to the article linked to by [2] (http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/story...), the actual number in Florida is closer to 2000 people since 2000 people withdrew their welfare applications when they reached the drug testing stage.
(The comparable number in Utah was $2000/person, if we assume Utah's program had no deterrent effect whatsoever. Arizona's program seems less effective, likely because the drug tests were easy to avoid - just don't tell the welfare clerk you do drugs and you can skip the test.)
...46.2 million people...lived below the official poverty level...10.4 million individuals were among the “working poor” in 2011... The working poor are persons who spent at least 27 weeks in the labor force (that is, working or looking for work )
You're not accounting for those that have given up looking for jobs. Additionally, the report mentions that children are also included in the 46.2 million people below the poverty level. Also, if you know anything about the workings of Temporary Assistance for Need Familiies (TANF), the main federal block grant for welfare as defined under the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (PRWORA), then you know that 1) welfare recipients must work for 24 months to continue receiving welfare, and 2) that there is a 5-year lifetime limit on being in welfare [1]. So, though your report mentions that most people below the federal poverty line, there's plenty of evidence to assume 1) those who aren't working are also not on welfare, with the possibility that 2) those who aren't looking for work have simply given up, as is the case for many, many Americans post-2008 recession.
> Your source [2] also disagrees with you.
Clarification, if anything the source disagrees with itself since the entirety of my use of it was within quotation marks. That said, I don't think it does disagree with itself. 1) We have no idea what the welfare/person spending was, as you note, so it's "silly" to assume that there were obvious net savings when we simply don't have the data. If you're not willing to trust the source on that, then at least trust the numbers for Arizona and Utah. Secondly, you say that "the actual number in Florida" was close to 2000, that 2000 people withdrew their applications when reaching the drug testing stage. You're obviously implying that they withdrew because they were on drugs and wary of not passing the test. You fail to mention the financial aspect to the drug tests--the welfare applicants themselves had to pay for the drug test according to the source you link to [2]. It was highly plausible, as noted in the article, that the ones who didn't take the test couldn't net that amount of cash.
As to Florida's program itself, it was deemed unconstitutional and stopped since it "unconstitutionally mandated searches without suspicion."[2] This was for the same reason you note that the Arizona program was "less effective"--namely because it didn't assume that just because a person was poor, they were using drugs.
[1] http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d0258.pdf
[2] http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/story...
I certainly am accounting for those who've given up. They are "not looking for work", i.e. not unemployed. Accounting for children does change the fact that the poor choose not to work https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2130441 .
The fraction of the poor who choose not to work was low before the recession as well. http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2006.pdf
As for your assertions that paying $30 for a drug test prevented people from applying for welfare, that doesn't pass the smell test. Anyone who passed was reimbursed, and welfare pays well over $30 anyway. If you want to hang your hat on the fact that I haven't found a source proving that welfare costs more than $425/person, be my guest.
I wanted to trigger the discussion of paternalism using a stereotype to see what kinds of arguments for paternalism emerged.
Amusingly, the US state of Florida in 2011 enacted another one of those republican favorites, the drug test for welfare recipients. In practice it cost more to administer the drug tests than they saved by throwing the positive results out of the program, because it turns out that welfare recipients are far less likely than the general public to use drugs.