Obamacare Website Crashing Because It Doesn't Want You To Know Cost of Plans
forbes.com
forbes.com
> "Avik Roy is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute and the author of the Forbes blog The Apothecary. He has stated he is an "outside adviser to the Romney campaign on health care issues." He is a contributor to National Review Online, where he was described as a member of Mitt Romney's Health Care Policy Advisory Group."
Hmm, I wonder if this author has an axe to grind.
> "The answer is that Obamacare wasn’t designed to help healthy people with average incomes get health insurance. It was designed to force those people to pay more for coverage, in order to subsidize insurance for people with incomes near the poverty line, and those with chronic or costly medical conditions."
Um, isn't that literally the function of all insurance?
It used to be about spreading risk. Now, I'm not so sure. The reason the ACA exists is that instead of spreading risk into pools, insurance companies have been denying coverage to reduce risk. This seems like the opposite of what they once were.
And it becomes a healthcare + insurance policy, the latter protecting against the true risks, like an unrelated auto accident or illness. I.e. the now outlawed high deductible "major medical" plans that covered catastrophic costs but expected you to pay out of pocket for the rest.
Which of course is another reason healthcare has gotten so expensive and opaque, when a third party pays most everything. Your eyes may go wide at the total 6 figure cost of a major procedure, but since you're only paying a relatively small copay....
I would assume the article didn't bother because it has been so well established by now. E.g. see it tangentially in the infamous "Of course, I want people to have health care," Vinson said. "I just didn't realize I would be the one who was going to pay for it personally." I cite elsewhere in this discussion http://www.mercurynews.com/nation-world/ci_24248486/obamacar...
Saying "because it's so well established" 14 days after the website opened, when most people can't even get onto the site, and a vast majority of people aren't even trying... is BS.
You're claiming it's "a very small handful" simply tells me your normal sources of information aren't seriously covering this problem.
As a totally insignificant data point, my company told us that our insurance was staying the same price this year, and we only have 166 people in the US, so it's not like we're some huge corporation that has a ton of clout to keep our costs down.
These complaints about an individual's premium going up massively (e.g. 100%) under ACA appear to be mostly the result of extremely limited plans being phased out and replaced with more comprehensive ones. That is, the old cheap plan barely covered anything but technically qualified as insurance. The new, more expensive plan that's the minimum includes much more broad coverage. Part of tackling extremely high costs for health care is having more things covered so providers don't have to write them off; currently people with little or no insurance coverage get care and stick the rest of us with the costs. The idea here is to expand the coverage so those folks who used to have pseudo-insurance that didn't actually cover much would have proper coverage (which costs more than the skimpy plan they previously had).
It is a pain and a burden for some people? Sure, just like everything else in life. Policies change all the time and there are always winners and losers; the best policy in the world ends up impacting someone negatively. Discussing issues like adults means understanding this and not simply ignoring the good and the sensible so we can shriek and moan about the bad bits.
I've read there's around 10 things including that clearly indefensible one mandated; perhaps these are on top of the now outlawed high deductible major medical true insurance plans that I've bought in times past. Without going through the entire list your thesis is a also indefensible.
And then there's stuff like the 2.3% excise tax on medical devices. You can't deny that that doesn't raise costs across the board.
Another thing I wonder about: somewhere on the net there's a general tools for looking at Obamacare policy costs. Someone ran a bunch of scenarios on it and he found that there was not a single one where being married wasn't more expensive that living together....
Anyway, you may say this is better, and it could be a legitimately debatable point, but it ignores one of the major points the article makes:
"But the laws’ supporters and enforcers don’t want you to know that, because it would violate the President’s incessantly repeated promise that nothing would change for the people that Obamacare doesn’t directly help. If you shop for Obamacare-based coverage without knowing if you qualify for subsidies, you might be discouraged by the law’s steep costs."
The Obamacare that was sold to the public was a lie. It's hard to see how lying to take control of 1/6th of the economy is going to end well, no matter how much the site can disguise it for some people.
We're already getting some delightful gems like http://www.mercurynews.com/nation-world/ci_24248486/obamacar...
""I was laughing at Boehner -- until the mail came today,"
Waschura said, referring to House Speaker John Boehner, who is leading the Republican charge to defund Obamacare.
"I really don't like the Republican tactics, but at least now I can understand why they are so pissed about this. When you take $10,000 out of my family's pocket each year, that's otherwise disposable income or retirement savings that will not be going into our local economy."
Both Vinson and Waschura have adjusted gross incomes greater than four times the federal poverty level -- the cutoff for a tax credit. And while both said they anticipated their rates would go up, they didn't realize they would rise so much.
"Of course, I want people to have health care," Vinson said. "I just didn't realize I would be the one who was going to pay for it personally.""
Your point about Obama's promise that nothing would change for people who aren't directly helped has some validity to it. People who had very minimal plans and were happy with those are forced into more extensive (and expensive) plans; that's clearly true. What he should have said was that nothing has to change for people who already have insurance plans that meet the minimum standard (which is a lot of us).
As for the linked article, it clearly illustrates that, as with every other policy in the history of the world, there are winners and losers. Waschura's case would seem to be an outlier.
Nah, that wouldn't have been true either. All insurance plans got more expensive to maintain under the hood due to things like the 3:1 pricing restriction. As a result, some people whose plans "met the minimum" in terms of what they covered are losing coverage because their employers can't afford it any more. Employers are dropping domestic partner coverage and forcing part-timers who would have been covered to drop their hours so they aren't anymore - that stuff would even affect people who had plans that "meet the minimum" in terms of benefits.
> Waschura's case would seem to be an outlier.
The 3:1 restriction makes healthcare plans significantly more expensive for pretty much anybody under 50. If you're under 50, relatively healthy, and making enough that the subsidies don't seriously kick in, you're probably in the same boat as Waschura (though the specific numbers will vary). Which is a hell of a lot of people, not just a few "outliers".
And, yeah, we should not forget all those who are losing family or 30+ hours/week coverage, the stories about them are legion.
Further, right now we're all paying for people who get care and don't/can't pay, so we have to make sure we don't double count costs. In the same way, if people previously got coverage via Medicaid but will now have a subsidized insurance plan, we shouldn't double count those expenditures.
Nope, I don't think that will happen at all. Because: competition. If young people are suddenly paying higher premiums than is actuarially appropriate, competing private firms that happen to mostly serve a lot of young people will have a windfall bonus, which they will in short order find ways to compete away until there aren't any excess profits to be had from the young people to subsidize the old people.
Remember how under airline rate regulation, planes tended to fly half-empty and meals were free? Stuff like that. Firms will waste money on really expensive real estate next to universities, on gyms, on salaries of doctors and admins that specialize in young-people problems. Meanwhile firms will do everything they can to subtly discourage old people from joining up and to make the service old people get as mediocre as possible while still staying mostly within the letter of the law.
Companies that used to be especially good at providing service to the old (albeit for a higher price) will tend to go broke, being replaced with companies that are really good at getting the laws bent in their favor and cutting corners.
The cost to provide care to the young will rise through "improvements" the customers don't value as much as they cost; the cost to provide care to the old will decline through degradation that's not worth the money it saves. (Until eventually 3:1 is actually the correct relative valuation of the service provided.)
We have a free-rider 'problem' here because of the disgusting prices. I'd gladly buy health care coverage (which I'd never use) if it were about as cheap as my car insurance.
If you don't call the patients who do that without any coverage "free riders", I'm not sure what to say.
And obviously this is why we don't have very many horror stories of people denied treatment.
CMS claims otherwise, but there are convincing analyses that Medicare overall shifts costs to others.
And what about the rest of the world forcing drug companies to sell their products as a bit about cost? Our market pays for nearly all new drug development costs ... which of course many want to "fix".
Surely some people walk in the door without coverage and then - here's a shock - pay their bill later. You know, with actual money. Possibly after a bit of negotiation, but still...
"Nationwide, the uninsured account for nearly a fifth of emergency department visits.
[...]
Last year, MedStar Washington reported delivering $107.2 million in care for which it was not reimbursed. Nationwide, the total amount of uncompensated care provided to the uninsured reached an estimated $56 billion in 2008, according to one study."
And there a very few extreme outliers who make more than a hundred visits a year.
Anyway, my point stands, I can trivially point to one major class of free riders, which deflates wild claims that it's all the fault of greedy corporations.
http://www.thestar.com/business/2007/06/13/theft_costing_wal...
Or to try to compare the two, Walmart U.S., not including 622 Sams Clubs, has 4118 locations (http://corporate.walmart.com/our-story/locations). So the most conservative estimate would be $3 billion/4118, or about $730K per store. About $635K if the clubs are included. If that's the whole world, about $275K (all rounded to a multiple of 5K).
Which puts Wal-Mart in tall cotton compared to that hospital.
And to compare a store to the hospital, you'd have to take into account gross revenue. Bet that hospital takes in a hell of a lot more than an average Wal-Mart.
I'd put good money that shrinkage is in the same order of magnitude after you take all the relevant factors into account. And if you were to take into account actual costs, rather than those reported by the hospital, it would be a lot less.
Those folks who paid almost nothing but still got coverage were healthy, young people, who have many fewer costly medical problems than older people. You can be sure that they paid enough in premiums for the insurance companies to make a profit on them (on average) after paying for their medical expenses, since insurance companies are for-profit businesses that don't like to lose money.
The fact that they were only paying their own way and not subsidizing someone else's insurance rates by overpaying for their own coverage doesn't sound like a "free ride" to me.
Consider car insurance: Should middle-aged drivers with clean driving records (who pay the lowest rates) pay higher rates so that teenagers, who get into more accidents, can have more affordable rates? Or should the rates be proportional to the amount the insurance company has to pay out for a particular group of drivers? If "health insurance" is really insurance against a predictable set of risks, why should it be different from auto insurance?
"the agency wanted to ensure that users were aware of their eligibility for subsidies that could help pay for coverage, before they started seeing the prices of policies."
Yes. So? There's basically three ways they could have approached this:
1.) They could show the "lowest possible price" anyone could get, and then have individuals suffer sticker shock when they log in and it turns out they make more than $5k a year and don't have 8 kids (or whatever else entitles you to the best discounts).
2.) They could show the highest possible price, and have individuals not even bother to sign up, because they assume they can't afford the insurance, even though they may get huge discounts due to their particular circumstances.
3.) They could force you to log in first, so they make sure they only show you prices that apply to you, avoiding either of the sticker shocks above.
#1 is underhanded and misleading (and is what typical corporations do with "up to 80% off or up to $3000 cash back!! (some restrictions apply)"
#2 would scare away the people who are among the people who need insurance the most and would get the most help from the law.
So... they went with #3. It's a usability faux pas, but at least they're being honest without scaring people away.
The process that the article is claiming doesn't allow researchers or individuals to ask these sort of "what if" questions. Wondering why is entirely legitimate.
But if the system disallows window shopping once IDed, e.g. plugging in different, by definition unverifiable income figures, family structures, etc., then the highest level thesis is supported.