All successful companies are alike. Each failure fails in its own way.
Of course they did a lot of things right and it's worthwhile to listen to how they accomplished that, but if you were to duplicate exactly what they did you wouldn't necessarily be successful. So clearly there is something more to it.
In any case, there will be bad advice coming from both successes and failures. To eliminate all the "failures" as having "terrible insights" is short-sighted.
PS: I'm NOT a YC alum. And my bootstrapped company is running with revenues.
Aside from that, most of the people reading are in the "doing nothing" category (I'm largely in this category myself when it comes to startups, though I have tried and failed before), and so it behooves them to listen to the failures. :-)
If you really want to get in-depth wisdom, you need to talk to a founder who has previously failed trying to do something awesome that no one has ever managed to do before.
The secret lessons can only be found at rock-bottom. They are just lying around there, because no one can be bothered going there and picking them up. So, go there.