It's not evil, it's just incompetent and embarrassing.
It's not evil, it's just incompetent and embarrassing.
And anyone who has worked in the industry over a long period of time will know that for big projects this closer to the norm than the exception.
I've personally worked on one massive banking project in the 90s that turned into a billion (in today’s terms) dollar right-off and in that time I read of many other such disasters.
Here's an alternate scenario:
1. The government agency that hired the contractors does not completely understand the business requirements in a way that allows them to effectively communicate them to the contractor. This could be due to numerous factors outside their control such as changing legislation or perhaps because the ACA is so large (900+ pages) and relatively new that there are few experts who understand the minute details sufficiently to specify how the exchange should work.
2. New requirements emerge at the last minute, requiring the contractor to make significant changes. While it is recognized that additional schedule time would be needed to sufficiently implement and test the required features, there is enormous pressure (political and otherwise) to adhere to the October 1 release date, so the implementation of the features is rushed and QA is skipped.
3. There are dependencies on legacy government and commercial systems that are outside the control of the contracting agency and the contractor. The functionality of these systems impact reliability and performance, introduce strange bugs, etc.
5. The software is delivered on time but is woefully inadequate.
While I wouldn't rule out the incompetence of the technical staff, these types of issues can often be traceable to problems that are more in the realm of management.
All states were supposed to have their own exchanges. 14 ended up doing it. New York after all sorts of political machinations agreed to run their own exchange at the 11th hour. (Supposedly "unprecedented" traffic also screwed up the NY exchange, which was also built by some big government contracting firm -- CSC)