Tesla Motors CEO: Let Me Run Detroit
wired.com
wired.com
Tesla has consistently delivered late, made numerous financial and legal missteps, and they've underestimated (dramatically) the cost of producing their cars (the Tesla roadster is more than twenty grand more expensive than the early price estimates). That's not to say they aren't learning fast enough, or that they won't build a great car company...I just think it's early to suggest that Elon Musk is a genius at running a car company at this point in time.
sensationalist statements + tesla being a successful car company in this economic climate = national coverage
But they're not successful yet, that's the point. (Of course, this is under the crazy assumption that we're defining business "success" as turning a profit)
Sounds like he's begging for a cookie.
PayPal only just dodged this bullet. After they merged with X.com, the new CEO wanted to switch to Windows—even after PayPal cofounder Max Levchin showed that their software scaled only 1% as well on Windows as Unix. Fortunately for PayPal they switched CEOs instead. - http://www.paulgraham.com/startupmistakes.html
I think what is simple is that Musk ignored technical reality based on a personal whim, and seemingly let personal conflicts get in the way of sound technical decision-making for a multi-million (soon to be billion) dollar business.
That typo is an interesting coincident given the recent lawsuit by Eberhard (one of Tesla's two founders who was ousted by Elon). It seems like Musk is using Wired to publicly disparage him: “I said .. 'There will be no assholes.' I fired someone for being an asshole. And I only had to do that once, actually.”
While I'm no fan of Detroit's management this Silicon Valley in-fighting is definitely not what they need.
Additionally, 1/2 of "Detroit", Ford Motor Company, while not posting stellar returns has managed to stay viable and not take any government bailout money. We will see what the future brings...
So, what he is really saying is "Let me run GM", a job for which he is fully underqualified and unprepared for.
Paypal was a pretty big success for him. It is unclear if that was more skill or luck, although it seems like it lands on the side of luck if I had to pick one or the other. Paypal also gained a rightfully earned reputation, even before ebay bought them, for having fairly horrible customer service. Maybe Elon's plan for fixing GM is just to randomly deny valid warranty claims and seize customer cars without warning (you could file a dispute process though, if you really wanted to).
Yeah, this whole thing is a PR stunt, but it kind of makes him (IMO) come off looking like an ass. I might feel differently if his tenure at Tesla has produced something that has a chance of being a free standing viable car company, but that is so far not a foregone conclusion.
What other modern consumer brand manages the entire eco-system from design to sale? (somewhat ignoring the fact that the Tesla Roadster parts was sourced by Lotus, the Tesla sedan I believe is completely an in house product).
Even better, EVs with 100 mile range and an optional petro fuel or propane generator module to turn it into a series hybrid on long trips. I only need the long-range capability of an internal combustion engine occasionally. Why do I want to pay for the overhead of hauling such equipment around when I'm just commuting or running to the store? Essentially, that's what many of us do with our internal combustion cars. We drive a heavier, noisier, over-capable long range vehicle that's less appropriate for the short neighborhood trip, just so we have the long range capability available, even though we use it only occasionally.