There is a theme park aspect to Silicon Valley but the Detroit analogy isn't a very good one. Plus, wasn't Digg in The City? The SF startups have traditionally been sillier and more prone to the party and gossip scene than the ones in the South Bay.
As to the theme park comment - it really felt like Disney World to me. I don't mean that in a bad way - I love Disney, and would live at the Contemporary Hotel at Disney World Orlando if I could. In terms of a supportive environment for building startups, it really is like a theme park ride.