I have to admit, that despite better technical specs, the user-experience with Xbox Live is just so much better that for any game I care for with a online-component, the Xbox 360 version gets the sale every single time.
As it is, I got the PS3 for near-free and hence have little emotional attachment to it, and these days have it around mostly as a bluray player.
I guess to make this comment relevant to hacker news and whoever does startups here: User-experience trumps technical merit. I don't care one way or the other if you wrote it in 100% purely in Haskell or some hacked up PHP. I want something which works for me.
Might not be a very cool message with the tech crowd, but as a consumer that's how I think. Heck I even ditched a technically superior Windows Mobile phone for an iPhone 3G and dammit if I will be going back.