SSN Required To Buy Palm Pre
yro.slashdot.org
yro.slashdot.org
I'm under the impression that most of this stuff is a complete racket though. Sure, Sprint can put several thousand dollars on your bill in one month because you used your data plan in Canada or something. But did that actually cost Sprint very much? If not, who cares if you cannot pay the bill? As long as you can at least pay enough to cover Sprint's costs, it shouldn't be a big deal for them if you simply owe them a lot of money.
Actually, it does cost Sprint money. If a credit card charge is declined the card issuer charges Sprint a fee. Failed billing is a huge issue for telecommunications companies.
I wrote billing software for a large telecommunications company and dealt directly with this issue. Something like 40% of all attempted credit card charges were declined for one reason or another. That is a lot of money lost to no good end.
I personally and single-handedly implemented the system which would attempt to authorize (not withdraw) one month's worth of billing from new credit card signups. It is amazing how many people hit their credit limit when you check to see if $45 is there. And even then a large number of those who pass that check will fail to pay their bill when you attempt to charge.
Asking for (and storing! WTF) SSNs to sign up for a service contract is heinous, I agree. But there is a lot of money lost to attempting to charge the credit cards of people who then fail to pay their bills.
My breaking point was reached when the local Snippets -- a franchise that cuts kids' hair -- demanded my phone number when I came to get my son's hair cut. When I asked why, the answer was "we need it for our system." I surmise that they want it for some sort of customer tracking database to use as a unique ID, but my refusal threw them for a loop.
Radio Shack was my nemesis, as I purchased stuff there often, when prototyping and not willing to wait for next day delivery. I used to get myself worked up before I even got to the store. Over the years, I've optimized it to just a friendly "Nope!" when they ask for a phone number.
Doctors offices and dentists offices are another one. Their little 'new patient' form demands much more information than they need. I leave it blank or draw a line through it.
When I'm getting my hair cut, since it's a more intimate relationship, I'm reluctant to be quite as rude, so I just tell them that I don't have a phone.
Pay as you go is where you have no monthly fee, and buy minutes ahead of time and have to re-up when you run out. That is way more expensive on a per-minute basis but much cheaper in total for people who carry phones mainly for emergency purposes.
I'm living in China, where they use SIM cards, and I just bought my phone and accompanying phone number completely anonymously, using cash only. When I recharge the money on my card, I go to a store and pay cash. If I want a new handset, I just take out the card and swap it into a new phone - keeping my cell phone number and contacts.
The flexibility has even fueled a boom of tiny cell-phone designing companies that make all kinds of innovative creations called 'shanzhai' phones.
Is this just a US thing? Or are handsets locked to carriers in most of the rest of the world as well?
Also, I think the success of pre-paid accounts show how much many people despise all the dirty tricks with contracts (like the $5000 bill when you had the wrong data plan, SMS fees, etc.) It also proves the infrastructure exists to prevent these kinds of abuses. By that, I mean limits on how much of a bill you are willing to pay rather than the open-ended, oops you should have read the fine print, unlimited credit line.
I can't find a link or think of a reference of an appropriate level right now.
And then somebody from accounting gets wind of it and shits a brick because the rules are different for money received for a service not yet rendered vs one that is.
Or maybe it's just a good business call. By not giving this guy his Pre, they incurred one hit of nerd rage. But they've ducked out on his followups about how unlimited isn't really unlimited, how megabytes aren't the same as megabits, how 3G speed isn't 2.99G speed, and so on and so forth.
Good point. :P
This is absolutely a real-world scenario. The difference between money received in a lump sum vs. money contracted to be paid in installments over time is a big one as well.