Hacker News Reader

HNHacker News

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Comment by lucian1900 | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

lucian1900·

How exactly do users benefit from DRM?

View on HN

It allows them to access content that they otherwise couldn't.

Isn't it the bad effect of DRM rather than a benefit!

DRM is only a hinderance to legit users. Pirates are pirates and DRM isn't something they deal with.

Uh, no. That's some impressive exec-level doublethink.

Content is open by default.

DRM is a method by which you prevent people from accessing content.

How so? This guy has a show he won't let me use unless I agree to try and control access. My choices are access with stupid crap like DRM or no access. Sure a third option like free access to everyone everywhere would be great, but that guy won't go for it. Until we can talk that guy in to going for it DRM increases access. Sure it doesn't grant maximal access but access is greater than it is without DRM.

Then "this guy" you mention is ignorant of how technology and piracy work and any rational person should push back.

DRM is not "necessary" by any possible meaning of the word. It's forced upon people by the ignorant.

Necessary in the way that a drivers license and car insurance are necessary to drive.

There is a legitimate need to ensure that people who drive both know how to do so safely and can handle any accidents financially.

There is no legitimate need to hamper fair use in the way that DRM does, especially considering that it fails at its goals.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com