If there are actual human victims, then prosecute with all the harshness possible; but if some pedophile gets off on 100% computer-generated images, well, then that's probably a win for society that reduces violence and exploitation.
If there are actual human victims, then prosecute with all the harshness possible; but if some pedophile gets off on 100% computer-generated images, well, then that's probably a win for society that reduces violence and exploitation.
For instance, if I try to hire a hitman and the deal falls through (maybe I do not offer enough money, maybe he is too busy to take the contract, maybe he is an undercover cop), would you say that my actions should not be a prosecutable crime?
In both cases the person fully believes they're interacting with the genuine article.
But if I try to hire a hitman on a virtual 3d character or Easter Bunny, it shouldn't be a prosecutable crime. In attempted crime there should be a victim that I attempted to harm.
I can agree that the entrapment / undercover cop scenario might make it properly prosecutable, depending on how it's done. I'd be willing to bet that in most of the cases if you'd get a warrant then you'd get evidence of actually harmed kids making the case very clear. However, if the perpetrator knows that the "target" is virtual and noone is harmed, then it shouldn't be illegal.
That still leaves a point about such "avatars" being legal if made/bough/sold for recreational purposes if everyone knows that noone is getting harmed. i.e., treating childporn as evil not in itself, but because it's evidence and financing for actual evil acts.
More research is needed. Some people suggest that users of pornography need to collect more and more of it. Some people who collect images of child sexual abuse are caught with hundreds of thousand of images.
A person collecting pseudo-photograph images of child sexual abuse might be a risk to children. (Data is tricky to find.)
But yes, if people can stay away from children and real images of child sexual abuse then pseudo photographs would be great.
(I agree with you about the bots too.)
Obviously it's very hard to test that, but it's at least credible.
The other point about pseudo-photographs is that it's a historical remainder from times before we had photo-realistic rendering.
People would take real images of children, and manipulate those into images of child sexual abuse. Sometimes combining real world children's heads onto real world images of child sexual abuse, or images of adults having sex.
In that case two images are created from one instance of abuse. Two children are shown, but only one has suffered abuse. Or children are shown, but adults were used for the sexual parts of the photograph. Since people thought strongly that possession of images of child sexual abuse was a signal that the person would go on to commit actual abuse they made sure to make these images illegal.
I find this very hard to talk about. I strongly want to protect children from harm. Images of child sexual abuse cover a wide range of harm, from sexually suggestive clothed posing of 15 year olds at one end to brutal rape of small infants at the other. My instinct is to keep these images illegal, but I realise that the demonisation of paedophiles does not help them seek help to stop their offending behaviour, and drives them to "support groups" that attempt to normalise their behaviour. And if we did proper research and found that virtual images reduced real world offending it'd be hard to keep those images illegal.
Or you could just as well argue that people use the imagery to fulfill their needs, and if they didn't have that they'd turn to actual child abuse.
'credible' should not be good enough. (Of course in the current political systems, it doesn't even have to be credible if you can spin it scarily enough: see war on terror, war on drugs, sex offender registrations for urinating in public etc.) You need evidence that actually supports your theory.
So far we have people who collect images of child sexual abuse, and some of those people go on to abuse children more directly.
We don't have groups of people telling us that their collections of images of child sexual abuse help prevent their offending behaviour. (For some obvious reasons, of course.)
The effort involved in collecting images does not scale linearly with the number of images collected.