> Why should someone who "seems sorry" when he pleads guilty get less time than someone who doesn't? Why should repeat offenders be punished more harshly for any given crime than those who are first offenders? It all shades into punishing someone not for what they did, but for who they are.
Because punishment has many goals, and one of them is removal of negative agents from society.
If someone seems sorry, or it's his first crime, there's a likelihood it will be his last crime, and releasing him earlier makes sense.
If someone is not sorry, or keeps committing crimes when released, then perhaps a higher penalty will at least somewhat deter them, and if not - they'll have less opportunity to repeat the crime.