If the OS handles it transparently, then sure, it could work. But as I understand things, that's why the CyanogenMod "feature" of selective permission disabling fails: If I ask whether the Internet has a valid signal, and it unexpectedly throws an error, then my app will either crash or behave in an untested way (depending on whether I'm catching top-level errors and continuing to run anyway). I don't know how the 4.3 feature handles it.
I don't want users to have the ability to disable Internet, though; not if I'm writing an ad-supported app. I don't want to kill the app on devices that simply never connect to the Internet either, so I'd prefer if the OS guaranteed that, IF there's an Internet connection, it will give me full access to it.