Maybe he should revisit his initial hypothesis that brain scans are quackery...
Maybe he should revisit his initial hypothesis that brain scans are quackery...
Raymond Smullyan is a fun guy; really good logic/puzzle books.
This is the exactly same reason why the FDA makes you form your hypothesis before you run a clinical trial, not after.
You can't run a clinical trial and say you're looking X, not find it, but then find Y (something you never thought you'd find) and have the FDA approve your drug. It's weak science.
Maybe, despite the evidence pointing in that direction, he just didn't manifest a psychopathic brain.
maybe.
I think a good answer is "if you care about the answer, then probably not - all a psychopath would care about is whether anyone found out".
In a scan like Dr. James Fallon (low frontal lobe activity) he could be impulsive and absent minded but not psychopathic. It all depends how the imaging data is normalized and interpreted. Also the PET scan doesn't show connective activity between neurons.
Disclaimer: I'm not a PhD neuroscientist.
If he understands he's an a-hole because he doesn't let his grandkids win, probably means that he has enough empathy to understand that his grandkids should win sometimes in order to let them gain some confidence, etc.
from what i get from reading about the stuff, it seems like a real psychopath would not even be able to comprehend that he is a jerk.
The guy says he had to check the PET machine before he removed the blinding.
He says his parents showed him a lot of love. he would have to understand how love plays out in other families to really claim that.
little things make me feel skeptical. but it's possible that he's a psychopath.