Breaking your legs to make yourself taller.
slate.com
slate.com
What's the compelling basis for us collectively to stop her?
(Besides, the laws of economics tend to ensure that supply will match demand when the market is left alone. If we weren't working so hard to disconnect all the market forces that go into causing that Econ 101 result, maybe our system would be less "overwhelmed". The food I purchased today did not take food out of your mouth; the medical services this woman purchased don't have to take medical services from you.)
I'm not arguing that we should stop the practice, just offering some legitimate reasons to limit this kind of practice.
It is true though, that if more doctors are performing non-health related procedures, there are fewer doctors to do health related issues.
The question is: How much should doctors be doing to make people better than normal, or intentionally abnormal versus doing things to make people not abnormal?
Plastic surgeons are already limited in what they can do. This article for instance: http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2002/mar/11/health.lifeand... which talks about wings, horns, tails and the like, "If the medical-ethics board allowed it..."
No, that's only true instantaneously. It's not true across a time span where the number of doctors can adjust to market conditions.
Once cosmetic surgery is so advanced that it is simple, fast, reliable and painless will people have any issue with it?
I'd be interested to hear opinions... Would you have a cosmetic procedure done if it was not a big deal?
The next step after commonplace cosmetic procedures is routine performance enhancement! Boron carbide skeleton, here I come!
http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/aimee_mullins_prosthetic_...
If anyone needs a break, you can watch the whole thing here (Parts 1-10): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N6zvCmQAHQc&feature=chann...
http://www.ilizarov.org.uk/content.htm
I have talked to wearers of such cages. Not fun, but they are a great alternative to amputation.
I mean, being short is generally not a good thing, except when you're in coach on an airplane and have ample legroom. But it's not bad enough that I'd willfully even break a toe to correct it.
It is hard to imagine that someone would put herself through this for pure cosmetic reasons.
Although in the case where the canvas is oneself, you can raise the objection of narcissism or selfishness, I think these pursuits are fundamentally worthwhile and even noble.
Instead of getting surgery, how about spending a few minutes working out and building up your legs? A few wall squats, a bunch of jumping jacks, and some towel hopping and you'll be just fine, without involving surgery that'll screw up your life 20 years later.
She doesn't drive.
Maybe I should have been more specific. The family member I was talking about had a condition called hallux valgus since her early teens. When she got older it became so severe that she could not walk extended periods of time without seriously hurting.
The surgery does have consequences, like problems with blood circulation and occasional numbing. But she is glad she did it.