What's crazy is that this particular Joyent employee is a VP of Engineering at Joyent. A person in such a position should have a better feel for PR, in my opinion. By claiming that Ben would be fired at Joyent and by publicly calling him an asshole without even hearing his position, he might've just have his own firing signed.
Unless, Joyent is the new Inquisition in this matter.
... except people who actually read the code and documentation ...
(for the record, I would have merged the request, as I like small fixes and think it's a good change, but I think Joyent's lynching of Ben is disgraceful)
While the documentation pull request may have been trivial, it was also risk-free. Ben Noordhuis chose to reject a risk free pull request because he doesn't like gender neutral language (instead of ignoring it and let someone else handle it).
https://github.com/joyent/libuv/pull/1015#issuecomment-29568...
Personally, I would have clicked the button because documentation is important to me. However a lot of people don't like smaller fixes like that. I don't agree but that doesn't make them bad people.
Gender neutral language(especially for non-native English speakers) is quite simply not viewed as an important enough issue to warrant retroactive application.
Should it be? Certainly; and while I think it's important that the change be made, and the developer informed about the importance of gender-neutral language in future documentation, I personally think that labeling a core developer of an awesome piece of OSS as a misogynistic asshole without even giving him time to respond publicly is an over-reaction.
It's a sensitive issue that should have been resolved privately.
If the developer actively continued to include gender specific grammar and denied future pull-requests retroactively applying gender neutral language then I think the title of misogynistic asshole would be much more applicable.
One denied pull-request and a revert does not a misogynistic asshole make.(imo)
Do you go out and actively try to increase the number of women in the field?