American judge proposes a ban on linking to online content without permission
guardian.co.uk
guardian.co.uk
It is as if he said he wants to prosecute football players for battery when they tackle an opponent. By stepping on the field in a uniform you are agreeing to play inside the rules of the game. Linking is one of the rules of the game on the internet.
Couldn't we use the legal argument that posting something online without taking further steps to password protect it or what have you is implied consent for the content to be linked to?
This would be akin to saying that a library's use of the Dewey decimal system to help you locate a book infringes the copyright held by the book's owner because it directs you where to find it.
The judge's proposal is purely a political one and that is why it appears in a blog.
Unless Congress acts to do a radical extension of current copyright law, linking of any normal type will not come under legal scrutiny of any sort, even from Judge Posner (who, whatever else he is, is nobody's fool). The danger here will lie with politicians who might succumb to lobbying pressure. It will not come from judges.
If copying content from a site is what he means, yes, it should be banned and that makes sense, but how can linking to a public URL be an issue? I just don't see how.
He also said: "an Internet was sent by my staff at 10 o'clock in the morning on Friday. I got it [Tuesday]. Why? Because it got tangled up with all these things going on the Internet commercially." And a lot of other gibberish about network neutrality.
But there's just no way it could ever go through.
My point is that these people might not actually know how the internet works and it is the fault of the court clerk not the judge if they arrive at a wrong decision. However, in defence of this judge, I think the article exaggerates a bit. The judge is speaking about a specific circumstance, not banning all linking.
Anyone who'd suggest "Expanding copyright law to bar...linking to or paraphrasing copyrighted materials without the copyright holder's consent", especially to prop up newspapers' websites, should be reviled by geeks.
And what's worse is that because they've got used to all content being stolen they value it so lowly that Amazon are prepared to offer the content providers just 30%!
Look it from a different perspective and bloggers aren't a news-source, they're ill-informed, amateur, unaccountable commentators. We need the papers. Sites like YouTube don't make quality content, they steal it and serve it for free. Google doesn't create any websites, it steals your money by advertising competitors products right next to yours.
I love the internet as it is, but I honestly believe it's not going to last.
User-agent: *
Disallow: /
This has the added benefit of reducing load on your servers greatly, which means you can get cheaper hosting. It's really a win-win.For the rest of your comment, I can't really say anything without being pointlessly snide.
Congratulations, you just summarized the Web 2.0 experience with a sentence fragment.
This has had the perfectly predictable effect on price (dropped it like a rock), with further perfectly predictable effects (eventually the supply is going to consolidate and contract some) coming in as second-order effects. The only question is timeframe.
"I love the internet as it is, but I honestly believe it's not going to last."
So, for that reason, it pretty much can't. Which isn't to say there won't be some "free-to-the-consumer" news, but there can't be so much of it.
That said, your distinction between "bloggers" and "quality" is already out of date. Ultimately, that's a form of ad hominem. Just as it logically doesn't matter where an argument came from, it doesn't matter whether a good bit of reporting comes from a "blogger" or a "quality" news outlet. Maybe one blog post in 10,000 is a "quality" journalism story, but that's still a lot of real journalism getting done.
(Just to be clear, since the presumption is usually that a post is an argument or disagreement, I'm not disagreeing or arguing, I'm further explaining. Except with the idea that you can completely, 100% write off "bloggers" as a news source as if they are some sort of distinct species or something.)
This is the same situation as, say, billboards. They owners don't produce any content, but they still make advertising revenue. (Other techniques include advertising on the back of airline boarding passes, direct mail, etc.)
Turns out that there is no rule or fundamental property of the universe that requires you to produce content in order to sell advertising space.