> Most of 23andme's customers were early adopters, especially when the price was much higher, I find it hard to believe the plantiffs in this lawsuit were duped into thinking it does anything more than claimed.
You've actually hit on exactly why the FDA decided to initiate enforcement action on 23andMe. The FDA has always taken the position that what 23andMe was doing was not necessarily permitted, but used regulatory discretion and did not stop them. The rationale was that since 23andMe did not do mass-marketing, the people using the tests were seeking 23andMe out and were educated on what the tests were.
23andMe has made some stupid choices, like not engaging with the FDA over the course of a number of months on this issue, and this was all brought to a head when 23andMe broke the implicit agreement with the FDA and started mass-marketing.
And on this point:
> that doesn't really promise anymore than a statistical printout of your DNA.
Their profiles now have a "key health recommendations" section if you've taken the test (I have), which, again, is a big no-no, and part of the reason that the FDA decided to initiate enforcement.