That constitutes fraud. If the SEC found out the company would get fined and the individual potential fines, asset forfeitures, and even jail time.
I suspect the bigger risk is that the buyer – the not-really-'accredited' – has some dispute with the company and sues, causing problems because the various assumptions-of-competence (that come with 'accredited' status) are then voided. It gives a bad-faith or disgruntled investor more leverage over the issuer.