Ask HN: Why kill duplicate discussions?
1. Some article/topic gets posted
2. There is a non-trivial discussion on the topic
3. Someone posts a link to an earlier HN post discussing the same article/topic x days ago
4. Article goes dead, discussion is killed
This model works well if the user-base is so small that everyone reads every article/discussion. But HN has grown. Why should it be killed simply because a different group already touched upon it?
What if the new discussion takes a different route? If it is truly the same article/discussion, shouldn't these be merged?