Ayn Rand-loving CEO destroys his empire
salon.com
salon.com
I'm not sure it's a good idea for a more reputable media brand like Salon to host articles like this, but it seems to be a trend -- Forbes for instance allows "guest bloggers" to post content that can sometimes be as unhinged as this piece.
Not sure the details of how he "pitted" company managers against each other but he perhaps did do an experiment in human organization theory that failed.
Free market ideology is not about pitting one manager against another...it is about measuring how much value the market (consumers) get from a given manager.
It sounds like this guy was anything but a free market advocate. Manipulating stock prices through accounting gimmicks is NOT the basis of a free market enterprise. The free market enterprise is always valued against how much wealth the market willingly agrees to part with in exchange for even greater value.
I'm not a Rand disciple, but organizational experimentation like what Eddie Lampert did is a good thing, even though it's been a failure in this case. We know so little about human organizations generally, and so few have been tried, that it borders on insanity to argue that the large business corporation, a form that has existed for only a couple centuries, has been perfected. Specifically, they nearly always have a CEO on top who has the power and trappings of an absolute monarch issuing orders to courtesans, who do the work or delegate the work to lieutenants, who do the work or delegate to lieutenants, etc. Are we so unimaginative that we think this is the SOLE way of doing things? Consider, for example, Valve's success with their novel organizational structure, what Michael Church calls "open allocation."
This is hardly a valid rationale for saying that what Lampert did was a good thing. Unless you're going by the "fail upwards" strategy.
The embodiment of an ideal is only as good as it's execution. Lampert's was clearly a failure. How can you call what he did as "good"? At best he was attempting a Sisyphean task (Merging Kmart and Sears), but then again, that was his idea as well.
Ultimately, I fail to even see that Lampert was punished for his failure - nothing in the article says that this corporate raider didn't do exactly what he intended - i.e., to profit by the destruction of companies.
Admittedly, however, it is probably unwise to play radical, untested games with the fundamental structure of a large and mature business, only because the losses can be so much larger and more catastrophic. Better to test the idea in a small or medium-sized business first. But it's a good thing for people to experiment generally, and we learned here nonetheless.
It would be unfortunate if the only lesson future business leaders took from this episode is never to deviate from the monarchical model of corporate governance.
>His notoriety grew in the early 2000s, when he launched a takeover of bankrupt retailer Kmart. During negotiations, Lampert was kidnapped from a parking garage in Greenwich, Conn., and held for two days...
http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/industries/retail/2004-...
>In exchange for his release, Lampert agreed to stash $40,000 in a garbage can outside a Wendy's restaurant in Greenwich, prosecutors said. The money was never paid. Instead, the FBI took up the case. They found that an associate of the kidnappers had used a stolen credit card to order a pizza delivery.
If you still are not shocked, let's color the phrase a bit more : "Is it really necessary for liberals to bash values they don't agree with, while hiding their own shortcomings ?"
There, you are shocked - but you can find additional food for though on http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2013/12/media_bias_case.... http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2013/12/denver_posts_me....
Besides this "Colorado school shooter was an hardcore leftist and keynesian" (shocking headline selected for additional emotional impact) this is not what I often see in the news http://dailycaller.com/2013/12/14/dead-colorado-school-shoot...
But I guess if the guy had believe in objectivism and had been right wing, this would have justified headlines and a totally different wording - like this article on Salon.
Ask yourself- why is it ok to do ad-hominem attack on one case, and not in the other? Why are you shocked when the headlines mention the political beliefs that you find totally normal, but you are not when the headlines mention Ayn Rand?
Besides the shocking title, the content is awful. This article has nothing to do on HN.
If downvoting this is easy, but explaining your disagreement is harder, my suggestion: bias at work.
But he obviously didn't help.
At one time Sears sold EVERYTHING, from a replacement zipper to a full precut and ready to nail together house.
They basically had Amazon.com -- suppliers, warehouses, nationwide distribution network -- plus a brick and mortar outlet in every town of any size, and threw it all away.
If they make a conscious decision to push one-way propaganda, they should not be linked to in polite company.