While generational wealth of the magnitude we have today certainly isn't productive, it doesn't actually do anything to impede peoples' ability to earn more for themselves, and forcing the wealthy to fork over money when they die is basically purely symbolic, because even when taken cumulatively it has zero effect.
However, I still disagree with you. On a micro level, that is absolutely true, there is absolutely enough wealth to be created from different places that it is not a zero-sum game. That said, on a macro level, it is a zero-sum game. Your wealth had to come from someone somewhere else. Sheldon Adelson's came from people staying and gambling at his hotel. Mine comes from clients, and theirs comes from their customers. Your wealth is determined by the amount of money you can collect from other people. As far as I know, nobody is collecting wealth from a source that is not another human being. Well, except for the Federal Reserve, but that is a totally different topic.
Wealth can be created, destroyed, or transferred. You seem to be confusing "collecting" and "creating". Wealth is created by people doing things that manage to satisfy demand...it's the right combination of labor and capital. This can take many forms, whether it's a guy building a casino or a starting a social network or a law firm. These are forms of creation, not transfer (or what you seem to be referring to as "collecting"). Transfer is entirely a governmental endeavor, a social mechanism for redistribution of the wealth that's actually been created. There is no labor, capital, ideas, or hard work behind it.
You are correct, obviously, that wealth is created by people doing things that satisfy demand. For the purposes of our discussion, wealth is measured in dollars. Let's say there are two people on earth. One has 100 dollars, the other has 0 dollars. The person with zero dollars creates some widget that the dude with 100 dollars wants and charges the other guy 80 dollars for it. Guy 1 now has 20 dollars and guy 2 now has 80 dollars. Guy 2 created his wealth (his 80 dollars) by doing/building/whatever something that guy 1 wanted. Am I thinking about this too simply? How is it possible that wealth (measured in dollars) is introduced into an economy without it coming from another participant in the market?
Guy 2 (inventor) had to employ himself, other people, and capital in order to create the widget. He has to pay those people and the owners of the capital, and in turn they now have income which they do "stuff" with. Some of it's consumed (spent) and some is saved (invested), in each case having yet more downstream effects. Maybe Guy 2 realizes he can sell more widgets to more people but needs to employ more labor and capital in order to do so. Multiply this sort of ripple effect by a kajillion, every second of the day, and that's sort of how it works. It's never stagnant, and the more activity there is, generally speaking, the more wealth creation is taking place.
But in a capitalist world, nothing is stopping anyone from being Guy 2, which is kind of my original point.
I guess it breaks down for me when you actually bring dollars into the model. You are absolutely right, widgets made of resources come from the combination of those resources and ingenuity. However, in modern society, refined resources are quantified in terms of dollars and once dollars are part of the equation, it must be zero-sum because people cannot just create dollars for themselves to buy stuff. They must create stuff to convert into dollars so they can buy other stuff. You can absolutely create stuff from nothing, but that does not mean that anyone is going to buy it, which would convert it into dollar wealth.
Wealth is not fixed...repeat that 1,000 times. That's all that matters here. Capitalism is a system that allows people - anyone - to create wealth. Hell, look no farther than all these crazy tech companies coming public, the saas and social media revolutions or whatever. Why are they almost always US companies? Why isn't this stuff happening in Romania? We have a system that lets people create wealth for themelves no matter how rich others are, and it attracts talent and hard work and all that stuff, and it becomes a big virtuous circle.
Anyway, my point is just that wealth in this country isn't a real problem. It is not suppressive. It's the opposite, actually.
If there is one problem though, and this is something more recent, it's that with technology we all seem to have our faces rubbed in others' wealth. This is sort of a real problem...sort of. There are tons of really interesting behavioral economics studies that deal with this and show how it makes people feel worse about themselves. A topic for another day I suppose...
http://blog.figuringshitout.com/the-parable-of-the-fisherman...
I hate to break this to you, but you dont have the ability to "fundamentally disagree" on something like this. Put simply, you dont know what you're talking about. You obviously dont know anything about economics, and to the extent that you've read something it's clearly been selective in order to fit your worldview. You can disagree with me and be wrong if you insist on it, because these things you're saying are fundamentally and demonstrably wrong. You might as well tell me the sun rises in the west.
These are the kind of lazy ideas that get people in trouble. I emphasize lazy because to genuinely believe this is like playing a game of chess and only thinking one move ahead. Stop for a moment and seriously consider what kind of effects a theoretical wealth cap at $5-10 million would have. What are those ripple effects, the unintended consequences of this? Tell you what, and I mean this seriously and without derision, why dont you tell me what you think the big picture effects would be. Would it be all sunshine and roses? It's a worthwhile thought exercise.
Also, you are correct that I am in that demographic. I am not exactly sure why that is relevant, however.
Many of the "poor" in our country are obese. That should tell you something. They aren't that poor. They have houses, cars, food, and clothing. Poor people can go to college for free (Pell Grant), eat for free (EBT), have housing for free (HUD), and get a check to pay for other living expenses (welfare). We have proven that providing all of these things to people with no strings attached does not lift them to a higher plane.
How will it help to take another billion dollars from a family who knows how to manage money and give it to a bunch of families who don't?
Well, for one thing, you are probably not neighbors if the income disparity is that wide. Secondly, you are really not comparing apples to apples. Someone making $100K/year is by no means poor. They make relatively less than someone making $10M, and they might be just as over-extended, but they can easily meet their basic needs, whereas somebody making $15K/year may have enormous difficulties doing so and as a result, might break into your car and steal your briefcase. That is how income disparities can affect your life.
The rest of your post is patently absurd. Food stamps in AZ amount to $160/month, and the maximum federal Pell Grant for this year is $5,645 [0]. For comparison, tuition for an in-state student at ASU at the college of engineering is $10k/year [1].
Not to mention that you cannot get sick or hurt, otherwise you are basically fucked. Are you suggesting that it is somehow easy to be poor?
0: http://blog.collegeup.org/maximum-federal-pell-grant-increas...
1: https://students.asu.edu/tuition/results?acad_year=2014&resi...
That's pretty much what the estate tax is.
Because your children didn't earn it. They just won the lucky sperm lotto.
As a society, our policies should be structured to discourage the formation of a hereditary elite.