The iPodTouch Is What The OLPC XO Should Have Been
wisdomandwonder.com
wisdomandwonder.com
My conclusion: Apples to oranges. The touch does little to teach you to be computer literate, and the lack of keyboard means learning to type isn't even an option. For the target market in developing nations, the OLPC is still better than an ipod.
So I'm biased.
That said I'd argue the OLPC doesn't do much to teach kids how to be computer literate either. Look at the screen shots and you'll see the thing has more in common with a $99 calculator than it does with a PC of any kind. It's design centers around a few specialized apps and the Internet which are both things the iPod touch does better.
So while I don't 100% agree with the author (a keyboard would be nice) his point is a good one. The OLPC is a lousy product that only gets by because it's aimed at people who supposedly have no other choice. But the iPod touch being at the price point it is means there ARE other choices which in turn makes the OLPC just a crappy project.
Poor people deserve great computing experiences too!
I wish that simply making slightly outdated equipment easily available to anyone who wants it, but doesn't have the economic means would gain more traction.
Even if the hardware/software is outdated moving from windows 95 to windows Vista is less of a cognitive leap than going from Sugar to Windows or Linux or something.
I think we sell kids short in terms of how much they can catch onto by playing around. I don't see the point in giving them a dumbed-down OS instead of a 'real' one.
Honestly, I'm surprised the market for netbook specific children's games isn't larger
This is a straw man. Of course mass production and competition were going to drive down the cost of access to the internet. The OLPC is designed to give children access to the internals of computation.
The original design was to center around the idea of being able to take apart and tinker with any part of the source code, and get instant results, but always be able to back any changes out, so there are no negative consequences no matter how much tinkering you do.
It was originally designed to let kids tinker with computers and programming.
Moreover if it's designed for kids in developing countries I'd think Internet access is much more valuable to them than development of their Python programming skills (meaning if there is a primary feature it would be that).
Perhaps a browser with access to w3schools and JavaScript is going to be better, though. Certainly cheaper.
By the time they are in 8th or 9th grade, they can use normal computers. No toy devices required.
The Guardian (event organiser) said that the videos of all speakers would be up within a month, so maybe you can see this very inspiring presentation as well.
"Explorable" is perhaps an even better term.
Squeak had the same aims. Skip to 8:20. You'll see kids using the software to explore robotics and do physics of gravitation.
Seriously, python is way better than objc from an elegance perspective. You don't need a crazy bloated cocoa API built on top with python either.
A book came out about pygame co-authored by someone in primary school. Not only are kids able to use python, but some also know it well enough to write books on the subject.
The ipod touch is subsidised by itunes/appstore/phone company. It's a console. It's closed.
ipod doesn't do collaboration well. Apple bans developers from talking bad about it - or tries to. It also doesn't have social learning features designed into the apps, or the OS.
ipod touch has a much smaller screen, which is poor for reading and viewing videos.
ipod touch can't be powered easily by a car battery.
You can't place the ipod touch on a desk, sit in your chair and play with it - with other children sitting next to you. Imagine laying the ipod on the desk... it would lie there flat. Fail.
The ipod touch is designed for a very different audience, and for different goals. To expect it is as good for teaching, and learning as an OLPC is silly.
Has the author even seen an ipod touch in a learning environment? Has the author even seen an OLPC at all?
I call uninformed ignoramus on the article - and fart in that general direction.