The success of pairing depends heavily on the skill and personalities of those involved. If the skill disparity is too great, you end up with one person doing all the thinking while also lecturing the newbie. If neither collaborator likes the other, you'll have issues. Even something like preferring different editors can get in the way.
In general, I don't think of pairing as good or bad. I think, "Is pairing a tool I should use in this case?" For me the answer is often yes, but it depends on many factors. I could see others answering no just as often as I answer yes.
Really though, you don't know it 'till you try it. If you want to get started with pairing, make sure you pair with someone who has paired before! If both people are inexperienced, the result is usually chaos and frustration.