I'm a libertarian. But I almost never vote Losertarian, because I want to influence the outcome. So, I generally hold my nose and vote Republican, the Democrat Party being the party of Big Government, the enemy of Liberty!
EDIT: And in parliamentary procedure, abstaining from voting is a valid option, and it is not a waste of a vote. You are specifically going on record as not approving of the choice being provided.
No, it's not a lottery game. But it's nevertheless desirable to have the best possible ball park estimate of the situation before voting.
E.g., if the candidates of the major parties are Bad and Worse, and you are certain that Worse is going to win, then you vote Libertarian (or for whatever your favorite third party). Worse wins, but at least you will have contributed to the protest vote total. However, if you are not certain, then you'd better vote for Bad, because voting for the Losertarian is only going to help elect Worse! That's what I mean by "influence the outcome".
>And in parliamentary procedure, abstaining from voting is a valid option, and it is not a waste of a vote. You are specifically going on record as not approving of the choice being provided.
A parliamentary body is a totally different situation. Many fewer voters. Much more frequent votes. And the votes are on the record, the voters having advocated their positions as effectively as they can.
Egads, if people voted for who they actually wanted, rather than vote against who they want the least, then maybe we'd get someone who actually, you know, represents the people!
The only reason you can be upset about me not voting against my principles is that I'm not helping your favored candidate over your disfavored candidate.
The winning presidential candidate does roughly represent the majority preference of the people. You make it sound like everyone is being disenfranchised. If you support proportional representation, or ranked voting, or some other change, I'd agree to that.
If you went around telling everyone that would vote for my preferred candidate to vote for candidate X that has no chance of winning, I might be annoyed if you succeeded. Unless I liked candidate X even more and knew you could succeed with everyone (or a majority anyways); but that's very unlikely.
"If more people refused to vote for a bad candidate, then the margin to win would be much smaller.
Egads, if people voted for who they actually wanted, rather than vote against who they want the least, then maybe we'd get someone who actually, you know, represents the people!"
So you're using "the main candidates are bad" as the basis for how the population should vote. It was more a bad assumption than an opinion.