Goldman Sachs might have been doing $100m a day by sniffing the NYSE
dailykos.com
dailykos.com
Regardless, it is pretty bad form to abuse the position that GS had, and I think like anybody else that breaks the rules on such a level that they should be kicked off the exchange completely, not just curbed.
Pretty much the grossest abuse of trust and position you could ever pull off at a stock exchange? If the sources behind the article are correct, then there's going to be massive fallout here.
Even physical access to the cables running other peoples trades should have been impossible, let alone root access on machines that actually do the trades.
All it took was some software in the right location, but they shouldn't have had access to that location to begin with. All they should have been able to see was their own traffic, on their own machines, hooked up to their switches, and beyond that you might have been in a position to do something evil.
Whoever agreed to the fox guarding the henhouse is going to have a lot of explaining to do.
In an ideal world, in this one I suspect they'll just get a tanker load of money.
Who's done this?
They had a perfectly good dealing room and they scrapped it after only using it for a relatively short period of time.
The replacement paid for itself in the first couple of months of operation... not a bad payback time on a $US 220 million capital investment.
Automated real-time trading apps run on servers, in machine rooms, not in dealing rooms. Hence the mentions of trading firms putting their servers in various exchanges' data centres.
Moving a trading floor / dealing room isn't really going to help, unless you think that human trader's mouse clicks or phone conversations are disadvantaged by a few milliseconds.
The trading firms putting their servers in the exchanges data centers is another attempt at reducing the latency, a server in the data center can react faster to a posted trade than one which is sitting at the other side of a bunch of wire or fibre. And it removes an extra layer of communications hardware that could fail.
Plenty of the trading is fully automated but from my knowledge of this world - which is very much dated, the last time I worked in banking is over 20 years ago and the pace back then was a lot more leisurely than it is today - it's such a competitive arena that even the smallest differences can add up to a huge lead over enough trades.
The trend is to try to get the human out of the loop as much as possible, and with every 'iteration' the deal rooms reflect this strategy more and more, where people are still nominally in charge but their role is relegated to oversight and data entry.
In the long run I expect the stock exchanges to morph into nothing else but racks full of servers but we are still some time away from that.
But to nitpick, the latency issue has got nothing to do with dealing rooms, which are rooms where traders, salespeole, quants and support staff sit. A human trader sitting nearer to Bloomberg's servers isn't going to make more money because they see the news 1us faster than someone a bit further away.
The fully automated stuff is where the milliseconds matter, and the data is analysed and the trades made on servers that are not on the floor / dealing room. They are, as we've both said, in a machine room or even an exchange's hosting facility, close to their own servers.
My point was simply that you won't get an improvement in "real time trading abilities" by scrapping / moving / doing whatever you like with the place where the humans sit. It's all about where the machines that run the algorithms and execute the trades are located. And that is not a dealing room (for big players at least).
A choice quote:
"Control of to network and server access codes is unclear. A number of shops run their network and job control operations with UNIX shell scripts. Bloomberg and Merrill are typical. Problem with shell scripts is that they get run with superuser credentials -- soon as you have 1000 scripts, everybody gets access to the passwords."
http://zerohedge.blogspot.com/2009/07/nyse-issues-correction...
And if you are not able to translate the technical concepts to simple english, then do you really understand them?
http://zerohedge.blogspot.com/
The writer is under a pseudonym but clearly knows his stuff and has connections. He is so well-respected that the NYSE is actually responding to his posts with statements of their own.
1. Someone working on high-frequency trading at Goldman Sachs was a Bad Person, as demonstrated by the fact that he seems to have leaked a big pile of GS's trading code.
2. The NYSE put out one report in which GS's trading figures were bizarrely omitted. (They've since blamed it on a "system error"; who knows whether they're telling the truth?)
From which the author somehow concludes:
3. GS probably hacked into the NYSE's machines or connections so as to be able to snoop on everyone else's trades before they committed.
Now, sure, #3 is possible. But the only evidence our author sees fit to provide is points 1 and 2 above, plus the observation that it sure would be profitable to do #3 if you could get away with it. (The reasoning, if you can call it that, seems to be: #2 suggests that there's more going on than meets the eye, and maybe GS were removed from the report because they'd done something Very Bad; Aleynikov knows a lot about high-speed trading systems; one thing an expert on that stuff might do that would be Very Bad would be to snoop on everyone else's transactions; so let's write a big long story that basically alleges that he did.)
So either our author has extra information that s/he isn't owning up to, or it's bullshit (and either wrong or just lucky).
The author's previous story alleges that Sarah Palin is addicted to amphetamines, on the grounds that she is quite thin and sometimes talks incoherently on camera.
Bullshit seems like the simplest explanation here.
Business types love their excel. Replacing these makeshift systems has kept many a software developer employed.