CloudFlare: Stop supporting the Target heist
cloudflare-watch.org
cloudflare-watch.org
Cloudflare does not host the website itself. If Cloudflare were to stop providing their services, the website might be inundated with traffic, or more susceptible to DDoS attacks, etc., but even if they terminated their relationship, this would not prevent rescator.la from doing their damage. The Pirate Bay is an excellent example of how little power one actually wields simply by controlling the DNS level.
Second, I'm a little concerned by the idea of a third party independently deciding that their client is guilty of a crime and unilaterally terminating that relationship. What if Krebs's analysis happened to be incorrect? What if someone had compromised rescator.la's servers and happened to be carrying out a false flag operation[0]?
I use Cloudflare for a site I operate, and I would feel more than a bit uneasy if they terminated their relationship with a client in this manner. Maybe OP and Krebs are correct and rescator.la are completely guilty. But what's to stop them from making that decision (incorrectly) in the future?
It's one thing to cooperate with law enforcement in an investigation[1], but it's quite another to appoint yourself the judge and make that ruling yourself.
[0] Unlikely, but the point is that it's hard to be certain of what you think you know.
[1] Which, as evidenced by the NSA debate, is not always so cut-and-dry either.
While I can't summarize everything he said, he basically brought up that CloudFlare chooses to take a hands off approach to managing their customers. This makes sense, IMO- if they choose to censor one customer without appropriate legal backing, where does it stop? Saying CloudFlare supports this is different than saying CloudFlare simply protects the rights of its customers to publish content freely.
In fact, Cloudflare also pays the price for this stance. Many of the fraudsters who either target cloudflare in some way, or aim to undermine it's infrastructure (eg DDoS services) actually use cloudflare, and CloudFlare doesn't shut them down.
The cards are out there; having a sketchy resale site routing its traffic, and paying, CloudFlare may be better for maximum long-term justice than forcing such a site to their next-best options. And given how often law enforcement itself has run 'carding' forums, for the purpose of eventually rolling them up, who knows what's really going on?
The same Krebs post also mentions a major bank bought card info from the site, to learn what was out there. Shame that bank into stopping that practice, too? Or trust that the bank knows what's in its long-term interest, since it faces more risk and has more professional staff aimed at this problem?
Also at Blackhat, CEO Cloud Fare destroyed Krebs on stage. It sounds like he did a follow up pwn at Defcon. Not that I put much faith in anything involving Krebs being more than theater.