I really hate titles that don't say anything about the topic, sadly they are more and more frequent on HN, I now stopped reading or upvoting those posts and I hope more people will do the same to these attention seekers
1. the students are self-guided 2. you have built a theory based on your observations
I'd suggest, for example:
"How is your mind not blown by students who seem to succeed through self-guidance?"
I'll think about another title, and I'm sorry (sort-of as I've enjoyed the debate here) for the sensationalist title on Hacker News, but I don't think it's a huge deal outside of this specific context...