Apple Puts Carl Icahn's $150 Billion Buyback Proposal To Shareholders
forbes.com
forbes.com
But $111.3 billion of that $146 billion is held overseas. Repatriating it is expensive - around 40% of the amount. The present dividend programme costs $35 billion annually. This effectively consumes the U.S. cash pile and cash flows. Anything more would require borrowing.
Why borrow? The bet is that the interest paid on the borrowing is less than the gap between what investors could earn on their cash (~6.45% long-run S&P 500 return less a risk premium) and what Apple presently earns (~1%).
>Spending down a cash pile is one thing, gearing up to finance one something of a different question.
This doesn't make sense - borrowing to repatriate cash isn't "gearing up to finance [a cash pile]." The cash is there, it's just overseas. If push came to shove it could be used to extinguish the debt through some other anti-tax vehicle or by taking the I-didn't-plan-sufficiently penalty.
[1] http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/320193/00011931251341...
But doesn't that also read: Apple doesn't have any major new (ipod-level or iphone-level) thing in its pipeline, so it is unlikely to make use of a war chest effectively?
Steve Jobs refused to pay dividends, he built a war chest for a rainy day. He was opinionated.
On the other hand, Tim Cook is weak. Instead of pumping money into R&D he is courting Wall Street. Dividends. Stock buy-back.
Tim Cook was hyped up as a slick operator, an operations guy who built up Apple's supply chain to be super efficient. Truth is, he is/was no better than any other operations guy using an Asian based supply chain.
Look at the problems with the iPad Mini Retina screen which have yellow streaks, or the image retention burning laptop screens, or delay in iMacs, or sneaking a couple of Mac Pro units out at Christmas.
Tim Cook has both pumped money into R&D and into dividends/repurchase... According to their filings, R&D spending (in fiscal years):
2013 - $4.48B
2012 - $3.38B
2011 - $2.43B
2010 - $1.78B
He has also put a ton of money into operations (paying for factories, locking in huge volumes of components, all available air freight capacity, etc etc). And a ton of money into Apple Stores. At the end of the day $40B is a lot of cash to put to work.Apple could hire 1,000 engineers at a cost of $250,000 per year and it would only be 0.625% of $40B (and it's actually more like $50B because that would be pre-tax). 10,000 engineers is still not far off from a rounding error.
Apple is waiting around until Democrats will let them bring back cash without a tax hit and then they'll make a special dividend. No financing magic needed.
I still don't rate Tim Cook though - he allowed Maps out of the gate. Scott Forstall took the fall for that one, but Tim Cook was ultimately responsible.
That's why Cook let it out of the gate, but fired the engineering manager responsible.
http://www.theverge.com/2013/10/30/5045894/apple-research-an...
If (a) the rate at which Apple can borrow to repatriate this cash plus (b) the rate Apple expects to earn on its cash is less than (c) the return investors expect they could generate on their cash, i.e. if (a) + (b) < (c), then yes, it makes sense to borrow to return cash to shareholders. Borrowing, in this case, is a transaction cost for skirting U.S. tax law.
Either that or it allows them to capitalise upon there cash asset in a way that does not open it up to current American TAX and allows more time until the American TAX system does some amnesty TAX deal for overseas cash Amrican companies have sitting and growing. Not just Apple, many have huge oversea cash piles and TAX laws have changed in the past to accomodate such situations and will probably happen again for a short term cash injection.
How does that work? I would be a little surprised if such a scheme had any effectiveness in reducing U.S. tax liability.
Is there anyone or anything out there that could even try this with Apple? Is that even really a risk for them?
It would seem in their market that any competitor or threat to their business would be spotted miles and years away..
In the case of fingerworks, it would seem to have been a fantastic act of value amplification for Apple.
The other kind, the kind that bothers consumers, is the kind that buys a company to keep the technology away from competitors and open source projects. FingerWorks definitely fits this description. I hope the same does not hold for PrimeSense.
But even if it were relevant, it's still not value destruction because future cash flows are incorporated into the sale price. I.e. Whoever is selling it thinks they'll get more for it than if they operate it themselves.
In this case consumers simply aren't generating enough demand to support the product - i.e. they aren't valuing it as highly as the acquirer does. So the acquisition creates value.