That said, I would love to see greater involvement of entities like Space X in a return to the moon. Space X has already proven it can do what NASA has already done, 50 years later, but at much lower cost. That's actually a pretty reasonable path to commercializing space. The problem here is lack of any market for the service. Space X worked because there was an existing market for launch services.
SpaceX replicates NASA's orbital launch capability with efficiencies to spare. The redundancy does not, however, extend to deep space exploration, landers and rovers, and sundry scientific and technological endeavours with limited near-term profit potential.
Okay, so Apple and Microsoft and Google probably could bankroll a modern Apollo program. But doing so would be corporate suicide. There is absolutely no way it would yield returns in any time frame that would be acceptable to shareholders. This isn't the web, where capital investments are small enough that investors don't need a monitization story. If companies are committing tens of billions of dollars, there needs to be a compelling story of how they're going to recoup that investment and make a profit. Space X had one: launch contracts for commercial and government satellites. There is no such monetization story for the moon.
Exactly. You could think of a project on the moon as building a platform, much in the way that the formation of the US was building a platform: creating something that allows other people to generate new wealth on top of it. The benefit to the originator companies of ownership over something like that would be enormous, without them having to do all the work.
You're assuming the entire cost needs to be bankrolled by a single entity or company. No such assumption needs to be made.
> There is no such monetization story for the moon.
North America was less interesting to European monarchies of the 16th and 17th centuries than South America, because they didn't think they'd find any gold there. Never mind the millions of acres of fertile land, or the opportunity to build a platform that would allow millions of people to create new wealth with the right incentives. Confusing the concepts of wealth and money, they turned down the opportunity of acquiring wealth because it didn't look like money. I think you are making a similar mistake. It's not a personal criticism per se: just like it would have been perfectly normal to assume kings and queens were right not to be interested in North America at the time, it's perfectly normal to assume big corporations would be right not to be interested in the moon today.