You mean that it's optional for users because the can "call this number to opt in for porn and dissident information" or optional because the handful (4) of ISPs who control most people's access to the internet have the option of "making progress on this issue" or else they will have progress made for them. Do these 4 companies need the government for contracts? How about broadcast licenses?
The thin veneer of optionality is (IMO, of course) the most offensive part of this.
I realize I'm sounding shrill and dramatic but… optional here is just a steam vent. The proudly perverted, politically active or other fringe people will be able to access anything easily enough. They're hard to control anyway. The happy 90% will make do with approved content.
Aren't we going in circles? If they can make it that easy to opt out, why not make it that easy to opt in? Isn't the whole premise that it's too hard and you can't expect normal people to opt in to a porn filter?
Now they also have to go on a now pervert list.
So .. you actually can tell your ISP that you're more into alcohol and nudity, but dislike porn? Tasteless would be nice, though?
I wonder if they wouldn't be more helpful if they'd just take the list of keywords/categories from YouPorn so that you can express your preferences in a better and more specific way..
I agree with your general point, but I don't think these things should be conflated. Having to state one's stance towards any kind of content is different from someone watching over your shoulder.
Sure, you _can_ opt out completely (not sure if that means that the BT site lists you as looking for all of that though, which might scare users again: "What, no I don't need tasteless material!").
Still, the UI leads you to state what you want (custom) or some predefined presets for all I can tell. That IS close enough to saying 'I like porn'.
I don't argue that
- disabling the filter might have other/better reasons than mature content
- filtering is broken, stupid, idiotic and will never work correctly - and opting out for that reason alone is a good idea
You're basically saying that you're happy for someone to collect information that -- at least in prudish Britain -- could be easily used against you. I'm amazed that so many HN users seem fine with this, given the normal outcry when Google wants to gather something as trivial as your geo-location.
It's harder to get more optional.
^Kindly posted by itricsquid http://i.imgur.com/dWxORfJ.png
Honestly, I'm quite shocked how many HN readers see this as reasonable.
For what it's worth, I think you're sounding like someone who actually thinks about stuff. It's not a bad thing.
In theory this is what elected representitives are supposed to prevent - the stupidity of the masses.
I never heard of any 'volunteering' to get your DNA added, unless you mean via getting arrested.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/talking_point/8039149.stm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7532856.stm this page gives more evidence that people volunteer. It also shows how large the dna database is, and how few crimes it helps solve.
You are just wrong about id cards. The detica poll (2004) showed something like 80% support.
The 2004 yougov poll showed 61% support.
Even in 2006 support had only dropped to 53%, but opposition is only 37%.
And all the way through pepple were clear about cost being very impotant to their acceptance of the scheme - when asked about id cards costing over £25 the support drops dramatically.
Any support remaining for the cards collapsed when the estimated costs rose from about £40 for combined passport id card to about £120 for just the card.