Let's not get carried away about Twitter's role in Iran's demonstrations.
slate.com
slate.com
So as the protests went on, you could see that the media was using these Iranians as the center of their stories (and in some cases, meta-stories about Twitter itself) since it was so damn easy. They could simply reports on Tweets that were communally agreed to be "right", get a few file photos and stills off Twitpic, and package it all up as an update.
The problem, of course, is that Twitter is only embraced by a small subset of Iranians (much like it's only embraced by a smaller subset of Ameriancans). So as Twitter grew in prominence as a source, CNN (and many commentators on the Internet) started to see Iran through Tweet-colored glasses, to use a terrible phrase. They weren't getting much information about what older people were doing. They weren't getting much information about poorer people were doing. They weren't getting much information about what people outside of the main cities were doing. And as a result, they showed us a whole lot more "revolution" than there may have actually been.
All it takes is: "RIP Jeff Goldblum...plz retweet...kthxbye!!!" Soon enough, a couple thousand have retweeted it, and that makes it news, so CNN reports it immediately with no fact checking.
Most of the people tweeting were seemingly new users with very similar English language avatars. I didn't see the Iranians I knew with green avatars.
It looked very staged and not spontaneous. They could have been US government agents. The Bush administration acknowledged long ago that it is trying to destabilize the Iranian government from within.
Also take note that the green "opposition movement" is supportive of the old clerical power elite that has been in power before the current one.
Wasn't there a news story a few weeks ago that intelligence and rationality weren't that correlated? :-)
Edit: This and parent seems to be quite fun/strange examples of jumping up/down in votes over the minutes.
When people can't say anything of value they resort to the conspiracy theory shut up technique and attack others on a personal level.
>> It looked very staged and not spontaneous. They could have been US government agents
I am sorry, but that is just not sane.
Edit: Like this, then. It is well documented that Iranians were protesting until shut down by violence. Can you give a reason why anyone would have an advantage to fake that the well documented protesters would fake twitter discussions about it?! It do sound like a classic Middle East conspiracy (and USA/Israel are the evil behind it!)
I really hope you're a troll.
I don't say that the Iranian government are shiny happy people but the primitive binary opposition evil Iranian government, good US government does not work, not even with a nice and friendly Obama in charge.
Just beacuse you don't have a clue about politics does not mean you can call me "insane". I didn't know that this is a flame wars forum.
When you get older you hopefully will start to discern shades of grey. Apparently you still believe in fairy tales.
You argue the US government would take large risks to get egg on their face just to emphasize what is well documented anyway.
If you're not trolling, you're a conspiracy nut. Think about motivation and risk.
Everyone asks the questions: What is the cost, what can you earn, what do you risk?
Arguably, the risk of getting caught is high, the payoff trivial and getting caught would really help the wrong people. The CIA etc can just sit and watch this clusterfuck play out, without taking over twitter...
I find it amusing that you assume anyone thinking you're spouting nonsense thinks of the world in black and white. Your history explains that.
You're the troll.
Stop shouting pal. Just because you're shouting your ignorance doesn't become more accurate. I even cited a source where you can look it up what you decided to ignore.
That will be hard, considering your comment history where you've been repeatedly downmodded to whitespace for politicizing everything.
>Just because you're shouting your ignorance doesn't become more accurate.
It is trivial logic that astroturfing twitter doesn't have a good cost/benefit ratio here. (A short win in the daily news to bring home a point already well known -- against total propaganda failure.)
You prefer to argue a conspiracy theory that anything bad happening to Iran's regime comes from USA.
I'm sorry, but my considered opinion is that I hope you're a troll, because the alternative is depressing.
Clearly, Iranians are not sitting spell bound behind their computer screens waiting for motivational instructions pouring from Twitter. It is certainly possible that some degree of organizational support was provided by Twitter, but given the total control of the government over the infrastructure, it would have been a risky proposition.
On the other hand, the world outside of Iran was, to the extent that was hyped on MSM, in thrall of the of #iranelection tweet stream. Here, in fact, we do have a case of an audience that could have been manipulated.
So who benefits? Ask yourself if you feel more inclined to support armed action against Iran by US/NATO to "save" the Iranians.
Oh, I did consider who benefits.
Did you spare a thought to cost/benefit? And the risk of getting caught and how good that would be for the conservatives in Iran, that is frenetically trying to pin the uprising on USA (-: but had to settle for BBC! :-).
It's not sane. It is like a rich guy holding up a gas station.
Edit: The fourth comment, not the third (missed one, which was whited out too much from talking politics...)
Look man, there's a difference between fomenting a violent revolution by providing weapons and terrorist training and trying to encourage a grass roots movement for regime change in the face of fishy election results.
I don't intrinsically believe that everyone should stay out of everyone else's domestic politics. I believe that as long as support is nonviolent, there's not a problem with expressing it.
No. What I'm saying is: The US State Department should keep out of Iran, especially after supporting the last bloody dictatorship (of the infamous Shah) the current rulers have abolished. The thugs who tortured the Iranian people still live in the US and wait for the US invasion to come back. Compared to back then Iran is now a really democratic country. Back then there were no elections at all, he ruled like a king.
Thus any interference of the US government in Iran is very suspicious and far from genuine interest in democracy etc.
Also as I stated above this movement wasn't very "grassroots". It was the old clerics against the young militarists.
I'd love to believe there was genuine support for the people of Iran but to believe this is more than naive, not after the invasion threats to Iran in recent years and the whole history of anti-Iranian policy in the US. Don't forget that Iran has even more oil than Iraq.
Your doubts seem to stem from anecdotal evidence and lack of understanding of how Iranians use the internet.
Most of the people tweeting were seemingly new users with very similar English language avatars.
Twitter usernames are forced to fit within a Latin character set, so it's no surprise that many used English words (many Iranians can speak English, you know).
* I didn't see the Iranians I knew with green avatars.*
The tinting of avatars to green was a movement by others to support the Iranians, not a move by Iranians themselves. Although, of course, it is inspired by the use of green by Iranians in real-life to support their candidate.
Also take note that the green "opposition movement" is supportive of the old clerical power elite that has been in power before the current one.
That's not necessarily true. It is true that in most areas, there is no fundamental difference between the two candidates, and the opposition candidate was part of a previous administration. However, this is missing the point. Iranians realize this, and support Moussavi because of the differences between his opponent, not the similarities. Moussavi represents a small shift from Ahmadinejad, but a shift nonetheless. It's a shift that would give Iranians slightly more personal freedoms, which would allow them in four years to push for a candidate that represents an even larger shift, and so on..
That having been said, it's true that Twitter shouldn't be receiving credit for its role in the Iranian elections; the credit should go to the Iranians themselves. Had Twitter not existed, they would have found an alternate method of disseminating information.
That's true. That's why I expected some of the bloggers I know to go "green". Also they write mostly in Farsi usually, they rarely focus on the English speaking public. So I know quite well how the Iranian people use the Web. Btw. do you know the Iranian Digg-like social news community Balatarin? My blog has been popular there twice.
Also I do not refer to user names but the avatar and the language of the tweets. Most of them were saying "Where is my vote" etc. immediately as if in a concerted/planned effort.
"The tinting of avatars to green was a movement by others to support the Iranians, not a move by Iranians themselves. Although, of course, it is inspired by the use of green by Iranians in real-life to support their candidate."
No, the allegedly Iranian Twitter users started it. The "Where is my vote" crowd did it first.
"Moussavi represents a small shift from Ahmadinejad"
Exactly. People rarely flock to the streets and risk their lives for a small shift. So there is something inherently flawed with this "movement".
The revolution will not be tweeted. Whatever we have witnessed on Twitter it was just a faint echo of the real events.