Hacker News Reader

Comment by j2kun | Hacker News Reader

Inevitably? Strong words.

Sort of. As t approaches infinity, more and more of the simple parts of math will have been discovered. Therefore the only parts left to discover will be those which are more complicated; hence the overall idea is necessarily correct.

This would seem to be true as long as mathematics is discovered rather than invented. Otherwise I beleive that one may be able to invent generalisations that result in a simplification of mathematics.

It could instead be the case that all of maths is simple, but that complexity tends to appear whenever we have an incomplete understanding of a domain.

This assumes that the purpose of math is to prove things, whereas another worthy goal for me at least is enabling humans to truly understand why things are true, and not just what things are true.

No disrespect, but your purpose for math is entirely irrelevant unless you speak for the majority of research mathematicians.

No disrespect, but dkural's idea of what mathematics is about is no more irrelevant than sillysaurus2's or yours, and dkural's view is quite well represented among research mathematicians, first-rate ones included. For a famous example, see William Thurston's "On proof and progress in mathematics" at http://arxiv.org/pdf/math/9404236v1.pdf .

I have a mathematics degree from Harvard, though I haven't taken a poll of research mathematicians. I do think algorithmic theorem proving is a great field of inquiry!

You are misled to believe that mathematics has simple parts and not simple parts, and that simple parts are easier to "discover" than the complex parts.

In fact, the simple parts are usually the most difficult to discover. Why? Precisely because it takes extreme genius to give simple answers to mathematical questions. Over time complicated proofs and definitions get simplified and clarified (such it was with calculus, set theory, logic, group theory, and countless other topics).

So there's no precedent to believe that current mathematics won't be simplified in the future (unless, of course, you believe that all mathematics is complicated; but then you seem to be trying to make an objective point about complexity, so we'll ignore that possibility).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com