The reasons the author lists for why my freedom is suddenly so limited don't seem like they would really impact me all that much. So there's more health care regulation. And now I'm supposed to be panicking?
Perhaps not.
The reasons the author lists for why my freedom is suddenly so limited don't seem like they would really impact me all that much. So there's more health care regulation. And now I'm supposed to be panicking?
Perhaps not.
Precisely. I'm not sure topping the economic freedom charts is such a desirable goal for the average citizen.
Here in Hong Kong (#1 on the list) for example, I have the freedom to legally discriminate against employees based on age, appearance, religious beliefs and sexual orientation. I have the freedom to engage in anti-competitive mergers and monopolize the market. I have the freedom to pay peanuts, demand unpaid overtime, require a 6-day workweek, give one-week leave per year and not pay you for breaks. Freedom to run a toxic bus fleet and burn bunker fuel in my ship while anchored 24/7 1-mile from the center of town.
One can argue cause and effect, but I don't think it's coincidence that Hong Kong has the highest income inequality in the developed world[1] and one of the unhappiest populations[2].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_eq...
[2] http://unsdsn.org/files/2013/09/WorldHappinessReport2013_onl...
Freedom != opportunities
Maybe freedom leads to opportunities.
[1] http://www.tradingeconomics.com/hong-kong/unemployment-rate
By the way, "Hong Kong is one of the healthiest places in the world. Hongkongers enjoy a life expectancy of 85.9 for females and 80 for men, which is the third highest in the world, and an infant mortality rate of 3.8 deaths per 1000 births, the fourth lowest in the world." [1]
Depending on how you count it, measures of food insecurity in HK show about 1.5 million [1] (in a population of ~7 million). Oxfam in 2011 [2][3], for example, tracks 16% of poor households with children suffer from frequent starvation and 30% from simply not being able to afford enough food.
Homelessness is less severe...relatively. Surveys in the city find ~1000 people sleep in the streets -- and local weather makes this a less severe option than say...Toronto. You probably won't die on the streets in HK from exposure. But HK also offers a surprisingly unregulated housing market that allows for people to sublet incredibly small spaces and even stack rental units in a single dwelling like kennels. Estimates put 100,000 people living in these conditions [5] Significantly more live in apartments between 24-40 square feet. [6]
But this you could find out for yourself with a minute of googling, that you didn't shows you are simply trying to reinforce some preconceived notion.
1 - http://feedinghk.org/the-big-issues/hunger-101/
2 - http://www.oxfam.org.hk/en/news_1630.aspx
3 - http://www.oxfam.org.hk/filemgr/1630/FoodSurveyReportAug2011...
4 - http://www.cityu.edu.hk/youeprj/hope/homelessness.html
5 - http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2084971/Hong-Kongs-c...
6 - http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/headlines/2013/02/shocking-photo...
At the very early stage, the cost is high. I'm obligated to pay overinflated prices for insurance to support the life choices (pregnancy, drug addiction, fatness) of others. The cost is also highly unpredictable - it's based on my future income and the exchange website is designed to obfuscate it in order to avoid sticker shock. Good luck predicting future income if you don't work for the government/bigcorp.
And there are all sorts of edge cases where the regulations don't even make sense. For example, I live outside the US, but if I enter the US for 31 or 36 days (different websites give different numbers), I'm obligated to buy 365 days of obamacare or pay the obamacare tax. This drastically curtails my ability to make sales visits.
At the growing a business stage, it makes your 50'th employee very expensive.
I must be missing something because as someone who is growing a small business, the ACA (and its Massachusetts predecessor) has significantly simplified my life.
It isn't about what the quality of life will be like tomorrow or next year, it's the consequences a decade hence.
Those countries all have significantly better social security safety nets. The US does not because it is supposed to be economically successful for the majority, if that ceases to be the case things like a lack of public healthcare is going to become a significant problem.
http://sg.news.yahoo.com/singapore-falls-to-record-low-place...
And they have rather brutal corporal punishment for quite trivial things (swearing on an airline flight??):
http://www.news.com.au/national/beyond-excruciating-when-it-...
Economic freedom, that is the freedom of companies to do as they please, is often in conflict with individual freedom. For example, I find myself with much greater freedom as an employee or as a consumer in Germany than in the US, because the inherent imbalance in power between the two parties is leveled by regulations curtailing the corporations' freedom.
How free are you to start up a company in any given field? To earn income doing a task of your choosing? To spend your income on items of your own choosing?
That is the essence of economic freedom.
In the details it shows that the USA is still very high in certain areas - like personal freedom in labor mobility - but is getting marked down for continued and excessive debt.
I think the list is somewhat imperfect (Hong Kong is no longer a country, despite it's commendable history of low taxation and personal freedoms, now lost to being a chinese micro-state).
The discussions around healthcare seem to muddy the waters - although it is a hot topic I don't think it really counts for much as most of the countries above the USA have much more regulated or state owned health care.
Regulations prevent more powerful others from removing my own freedom as they want.
Microsoft or Apple can't prevent me from starting up a new company or buying some other product unless they get the government to regulate my other choices out of existence - which means they can only harm me by decreasing my economic freedom. The exact opposite to what people seem to be trying to say here.
On the right, we have the toddler. He is 2 years old. On the left, we have the heavy weights world champion.
Ladies and gentlemen, please make your bets. The fight is about to begin!
I'll restate again: Economic Freedom gives you, the individual, the freedom to pursue your own economic choices. That is the type of job you'd like to do, the type of business you'd like to start, how you'd like to spend your income.
It has zero to do with David vs Goliath, Corporation vs Individuals.
Case in point. Would you like to start a community bank, to better serve yourself and your local community? Have you got the freedom from regulations to do so?
Regulations, as we all know, are often written by lobbyists and passed by politicians. Frequently these regulations are designed to entrench power and escape from competition.
Let's look at a common discussion point on this site - Uber. High economic freedom means you're free to start your own Uber-like service. You're free to create a car service, and free as a consumer to purchase a ride from them. Low economic freedom means there are barriers from either starting the company or buying it's products. From such freedoms springs economic growth. Entrepreneurs require economic freedom so that they can find new paths, so that they can pivot around looking for the right business model.
That is why it has nothing to do with 'big vs small' or anything like that. Regulations do not make you free.
These seem orthogonal to me. You can have individual economic freedom.
Yes, it is starting to look like these 'crony-populist regimes' that threaten economic freedom actually make people a good deal freer in material terms.
There is of course some possible bias in this article that should be derivable from the domain name.