Would you run a company like open source, perhaps, with a lot of remote people? Would you pay feature and bug fix bounties instead of salaries? Would you change the way communication and knowledge is shared so that getting up to speed isn't a huge burden on the people who are productive?
I think that the way most companies work, you're absolutely right that false positives are terrible. But that seems like a problem well worth tackling!
Both you and raganwald are right, but the industry standard is a practice that looks like it was created to do exactly what it should avoid. No amount of generic complaining can offset that.
But all too often, I met with resistance when looking at Java opportunities because my résumé didn't have the right buzzword bingos for the gating process. I found it difficult to even get an interview with some companies!
Thankfully, things ended up working out in my favour.