Hits the nail on the head for me. In the end these people make incredible amounts of money for doing what amounts to a job that is worthless to the society at large.
Hits the nail on the head for me. In the end these people make incredible amounts of money for doing what amounts to a job that is worthless to the society at large.
As opposed to making incredibly amounts of money finding ways of getting Random Joe to click on ads? The only difference between him and most 20 something kids working their asses off in SV is a million dollars.
Edit: Also this article isn't about that sort of occupation. I was focusing on the topic at hand.
That is fair, I presumed you were making a moral judgement of the way they were spending their lives, apologies if that was not the intention.
Or are you just talking about the financial sector in general (and even so there were loans long before that.)
Wall St. does not exist so people can get loans to purchase houses/cars... You may be missing some points about loans vs trading here...
I'm not going to say these people are earning an amount commensurate to the value they provide to society, but pretending that they are just running a casino is equally naive.
Greater security and insulation against bad investments? (which to be clear the vast majority of people do not have enough money to make in the first place.)
Seems a lot like playing odds at a Casino, to use your example, to me.
And your edit is valid they do not provide the value (though there may be some, if little) that their millions of dollars in bonuses/salary would imply.
"There's an old saying in Tennessee—I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee—that says, 'Fool me once, shame on...shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again.'"
And to quote a head of a self-regulatory body in charge of such things:
In the context of a 2010 examination of the ICE Trust, an industry self-regulatory body, Gary Gensler, the chairman of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission which regulates most derivatives, was quoted saying that the derivatives marketplace as it functions now "adds up to higher costs to all Americans."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative_(finance)#Economic_f...
I would venture that none of these things benefit the 'average' person. Not saying its a bad thing, but the great amount of money dumped into this area of the economy, does not equate to their usefulness to society.
Edit: Actually the next section in the link you provided shows exactly how they can be a great detriment to economic stability including the recent AIG fiasco.
the use of derivatives to conceal credit risk from third parties while protecting derivative counterparties contributed to the financial crisis of 2008 in the United States.
However, the 2008 financial crisis showed that when tested, derivatives don't provide much of the value that they were supposed to (shifting risk to those who want it and will quietly suffer the consequences of failure without having spillover effects on the rest of the economy) which essentially retcons away much of that value.
Then your firehose-manipulation skills are worthless to society at large -- they reduce the net influx of money by $10k/year when you practise them -- but I bet you'd have no trouble finding someone sane and willing to pay you $50k/year to point the firehose their way.
(Of course in this exact scenario you would do better just to take the extra yourself; the real-world counterpart of the skill, though, produces gains roughly in proportion to the amount of money put in, and you can do better by persuading thousands of people to get you to point the firehose their way than by just working for yourself.)
I make no claim that the real-world finance industry is like that. But it illustrates schematically how something can be (1) of negative value to society as a whole and (2) something sane people are willing to pay for. And it's not unreasonable to conjecture that a lot of the things investment banks and hedge funds do have something like the same structure.
Oh, one other thing. Suppose that actually the firehose distributes money very unevenly. Then you might do this: manipulate the firehose to benefit one set of rich people at the expense of another, take their money, and give some of it to poor people. Doing that might be substantially net positive to society. So even taking this rather cynical view of the finance industry, some people in it might be doing a whole lot of good on balance. (It's called "earning to give" by the cool kids these days. But even if you don't explicitly give anything away, the magic of income tax -- if the government spends reasonably wisely -- may turn a slightly-negative-sum activity into something that benefits society on the whole.)
[EDITED to insert an accidentally omitted word and clarify slightly. No change in substance.]
Prior to winning the lottery, Joe worked as a janitor, and provided a valuable and necessary function to society. He made $10 an hour.
Now, certainly there is some qualitative difference in the reasons society valued Joe at $10 an hour before he held the winning lottery ticket and $250 million afterward.
Certainly we can say that there exist a range of reasons that one might benefit from a system, and that "people will pay for it" can be used to justify just about anything.
And the financial industry that people are upset about is not really the banks that provide loans (although there is some blame in the instances when people loan money to others knowing they have no hope of paying the money back). The loans existed already; without the loans there's no CDO to buy and sell.
The reason the CDO's existed was that the traditional way to make a loan and get your money back over time with interest was just too damn slow, and people needed a way to pretend the risk of a group of such loans didn't really exist and that they'd make exponentially more money in perpetuity.