I don't think anyone is arguing that an employer has a
legal obligation to give employees a share in profits, or to continue employing them at their existing salary when times are difficult, or indeed to do anything beyond what they are contractually obliged to do.
What I'm hearing is a different argument, to which your analogies with bonds and call options and forward contracts and whatnot are (I think) completely nonresponsive.
The argument goes something like this:
1. The success of a company is due to the work of its "ordinary" employees at least as much as to the genius or hard work of its executives or the generosity of its shareholders.
2. Ordinary employees are not adequately compensated for the work they do and the risk they bear. (This is primarily a claim in the realm of ethics, not economics.)
3. In particular, they share in the downside (via the likelihood of losing their jobs or taking substantial paycuts, if times are difficult) without getting much of the upside (via any sort of profit-sharing, or substantial pay rises, if times are good).
4. Yes, in principle, any employee is free to go elsewhere in search of better compensation (or other improvements) but in practice other jobs are often in short enough supply that there is little prospect of this.
5. You might argue that this means that they can't possibly be being underpaid because they're getting what The Market gives them, and The Market is the sole arbiter of what constitutes fair compensation -- but (a) if that's meant to be some kind of moral axiom then it isn't very plausible as such, and (b) if it's meant to be some kind of consequence of market efficiency, economists' optimality theorems, etc., then there are a whole lot of missing steps that look like they make desperately overoptimistic assumptions about what markets do.
6. The fact that employees are treated in this way means that in difficult economic times they are liable to find themselves in desperate situations. This is a bad thing. If employers were more generous then their employees would be at less risk of (e.g.) losing their homes, and society as a whole would be more stable and happier. (This is one sense in which it is possible for someone to be underpaid despite getting the salary The Market gives them: it may be that a higher salary would still leave the employer with a substantial gain from employing them, while making society as a whole better off.)