This looks one of those cases that could have gone like this:

"Someone proposed an idea that was perhaps technically legal, but obviously failed the sniff test of ethics and spirit of the law. I reminded her of what I repeatedly tell our staff at welcome/training meetings: At this company, we do what is right, for our employees, our customers, our investors, and the public. We don't mislead one to help another. We don't waste time splitting hairs about whether something smells bad or is totally rotten. If we're not proud enough of an action to want to see it on the cover of the New York Times, we just don't do it."