Primary elections.
Not the final elections - by then the incumbents are in place and it's too late ... for national office, incumbents resign / die more often than they're beat by an opponent.
Primaries are where the action is, for two reasons:
* it's the one time an incumbent is most vulnerable
* very few people vote in primaries compared to election time, so each person's vote makes a bigger difference
Want change in D.C.? If you primary just 10% of the critters there, you'll get their full, undivided attention.
Yes, emails, letters, and phone calls have an effect. So does K Street. Politicians care about their re-election and money / resources to make it happen, so in the game of influence, I (a normal taxpayer with neither the desire nor the ability to bribe them) will always have the disadvantage. That's why I'd rather fight outside their game - in the primary race.
----------------------------------------
More info:
Yes, these links are from a tea partier perspective, but guess what? The tools they describe work for everybody just the same.
http://pjmedia.com/richardfernandez/2011/09/13/storming-the-...
http://www.campaign4primaryaccountability.org/ One of the organizations in this space; there are others out there.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eSib8MfaQLQ Leo Linbeck describes the general strategy and how it can work.