What? Creating a compressed archive is exactly the sort of thing that Make was designed for. A binary file or library, if you squint the right way, is just an archive of object files, which are just transformations of .c files.
Make's biggest problems for me (and the reason that I'm slowly gravitating towards writing a replacement for my own purposes) come from the fact that it can't handle inferring dependency graphs correctly. The usual 'gcc -M' hacks that work for C source don't work for code where dependency tracking is more than just an optimization. For C, remember, as long as you have the appropriate headers and .c files, you can build a .o file completely order-independent.
If you have a dependency digraph that looks like this:
a -> b, c, d
b -> c, d
c -> d
d
Then you need to build in this order: d, c, b, a
Without some way of explicitly generating these dependencies ahead of time (which, I admit, is doable), you can't get make to do this properly. The best hack I can think of would look something like this: depfile: $(SOURCES)
update-deps -o $@ $?
include depfile
But at that point, you're pretty much generating a makefile with another tool, scanning all changed sourcs, at which point you might as well move on to just building the DAG and running the build on them while you're at it.Regarding your chained dependencies, how do you expect _any_ tool to figure this out without either being told or examining the inputs (which implies knowledge of their formats)? Relegating this to an external tool seems perfectly appropriate to me.
zipfile.zip: $(wildcard dir/*.c)
zip -ur $@ $?
Note, $? will only include the prerequisites that are newer than the zipfile, and therefore, will only update the files that have changed. You will not be re-zipping things repeatedly.2-3. This command does what you want: zip -R -FS foo.zip '*.c'
4. In practice timestamps work just fine unless you deliberately sabotage them. To use content hashes, the hashes of the input files when creating a target would need to be stored somewhere for future reference. This storage place could just as easily be corrupted. Make is a build tool, not a VCS. Treat it as such.
Yes, some things are specific to GNU make, but it is the de facto standard, something waf can only dream of. If you're going to complain about something being non-standard, your suggested alternative should be more of a standard, not less.
If you want bz2, why did you ask for zip?