Would you eat apples from a bag if there was a chance that 50% of them were poisonous? 25%? 10%? 1%?
And to be a pedant, green/unripe apples are poisonous. They make you feel unwell; they just don't maim or kill you. Plenty of people would tuck into a bag of apples where some of them were still not yet ripe.
That's the problem, combined with the fact that police forces are funded by force rather than by providing a service that people are willing to pay for.