A List Of Fallacious Arguments
don-lindsay-archive.org
don-lindsay-archive.org
A good example of one of those sort-of fallacies. In reality, everyone is biased, and understanding those biases is part of politics. Politics is not a truth-seeking endeavor, and so fallacies are very much acceptable strategically. Someone who surrenders his own biases, and also surrenders examining his opponents' biases losses every time.
over-simplifying. As Einstein said, everything should be made as simple as possible, but no simpler. Political slogans such as "Taxation is theft" fall in this category.
Right, exactly. Actually, all taxation is in fact theft. The nuance that is missed by people who say that, is that some theft is positive-sum, even to the victim.
Similarly, a common justification for bribery is that "Everybody does it". And in the past, this was a justification for slavery.
"Slavery: Everybody does it"? Uh, no. I doubt anyone ever put together those words.
I am sure someone rationalized slavery to themselves like that. "All my neighbors have slaves, so I guess it's OK for me to have one too."
This is how I convinced myself not to go to class in college. "Nobody else is going."
Twelve million Africans were shipped to the Americas from the 16th to the 19th centuries (according to Wikipedia), I doubt any of us know how every single person involved justified this enterprise.
Actually, it doesn't. Well, it certainly isn't the whole story.
IANAL, but this snippet from a web page accords almost precisely with my memory of what I learned when I had cause to deal with such a matter professionally:
> A person is guilty of theft if he dishonestly
> appropriates property belonging to another with
> the intention of permanently depriving the other
> of it ...
According to law, it's not theft if you did it honestly, or if you intended to give it back. "Consent" is not part of the legal definition.EDIT: I note that the wikipedia article mentions consent. These things will differ between English, American and other country's laws.
Certainly in the case of taxes the intent is to deprive permanently, so it comes down to whether it's dishonest. Since the government makes the laws, and the government won't want taxation to be declared theft, we can deduce that taxation isn't dishonest.
According to the government.
Theft, murder and whole pile of other 'bad' things are legal when the entity that defines what is legal and what is not does it.
That entity can be changed, that is why you have the vote so in the long run we all collectively determine what is legal and what is not.
That's oversimplified but it shows you that tax is legal and theft is not legal so therefore they can't be equivalent.
Theft is defined by the government, not by you.
Sure, if you're on a collegiate debate team it's great to be able to categorize the faults in your opponent's argument. But in the real world, we have discussions -- sometimes heated ones -- in order to advance some common cause. That means we should be working on each other's teams here. When somebody uses one of these, they're not "cheating" -- it's more like they slipped up into a simple response when a more well-thought out response was called for. Lists like this lead us to think we just point our finger and shout "ad hominem!" instead of actually engaging somebody.
Somebody can commit every logical fallacy there is and still have valuable and important information that you need to have. Heck -- they can actually have a better case than you do. If somebody runs in the room and shouts "you're such an idiot you probably don't even realize the building is on fire", the proper response is not to critique their argumentation skills.
I have the same problem with these lists as I do with design pattern books. The purpose shouldn't be to memorize the label and pattern, the purpose should be to develop enough critical thinking skills that you don't need the list, don't need the patterns book. Then the labels are just nice after-thoughts.
BTW, you are aware that 'cites an obscure logical fallacy in order to sound more intelligent' is something between an ad hominem and a red herring, because you draw attention to the supposed, morally questionable, intentions of the other, rather than face the fallacy head on?