The Evolution of CS Papers
tagide.com
tagide.com
Thus, truly practical research (yes, research) appears in blogs and "low-end" journals, and doesn't get credit. But which articles are actually impacting the general knowledge of humanity in a more positive manner?
The technical, mathematical papers have their place, but the separation of academia from the concerns of practitioners is only contributing to the growing consensus among politicians and the public that universities aren't worth subsidizing, that what you learn there is not applicable in the real world, and that college should be transformed into something more like a trade school.
The proper link is simply http://tagide.com/blog/2014/02/the-evolution-of-cs-papers/.
I don't have enough data to make a claim about what has caused this trend, but I do think it's a positive thing for the field. Opinion pieces don't really belong in academia. We need sources of objective information, and academic, peer-reviewed research is quite intentionally designed to fulfill that role. On the other side, opinion pieces don't benefit much from academia: peer review of opinions is usually just as subjective as the opinion being reviewed, and the nature of blogs and personal websites is such that they actually disemminate their ideas to a broader audience (many academic papers are behind paywalls).
TL;DR: Academia doesn't need opinion pieces, and opinion pieces don't need academia. Both serve important roles in the field of computer science, but they don't need to mix.
I don't understand why the Hacker News community tends to downplay the effect of pure CS research and the programming ability of people in academia.
The author of this article, in fact, seems to be a rather accomplished programmer as well as an academic. Here's her "about" page:
When I was in academia, I had the privilege of meeting some people with really impressive programming talent. And some of the pure CS research I saw had some very interesting applications, such as string matching algorithms that could be applied to DNA sequencing. (Of course, there were people who were extremely talented at bullshit too, but the quality of people varies anywhere you go.)