ADP will never be simple because it's not supposed to be. It also won't die for the same reason. It handles payroll processing
worldwide. Payroll is complicated enough when you're just dealing with city, state, and federal payroll taxes. Can you imagine how complicated a system must be to account for all of the international rules and variations of payroll
and make it accessible via a unitary interface?
ADP is targeted at corporations with payroll across multiple jurisdictions. The Apples, Googles, and Microsofts. It's not targeted at, nor intended for small businesses, even though they offer a SMB product. If you're not at least dealing with payroll across multiple states, you should be using a your bank's payroll service offerings, or (if you trust them) a local payroll service provider or a payroll SaaS.