Your argument makes perfect sense when you're talking about real companies, with R&D, marketing, technology and all that. GM buying Tesla for 15% of its worth might make sense. But in the social space, companies are entirely seasonal, the barriers to entry are none, there's no way to predict user traction or behavior.
I understand this is how Facebook intends to keep itself at the top of the social heap, but with recent valuations (starting at Instagram), it'll be incredibly difficult to maintain this for long.