Justin.tv is spamming HackerNews
They also all have the same number of upvotes, which strikes one as a bit eerie.
What's the story?
They also all have the same number of upvotes, which strikes one as a bit eerie.
What's the story?
I agree that commenting should be possible, though. I'm not sure why it isn't. If folks can't handle a civil discussion about the job posting, or if they can't be bothered to answer questions about the job, maybe a social news site is not the right place to post the ad.
I also agree on the fact that it is rather annoying and I think there should be some kind of mechanism where you could say "I'm not interested in job offerings". Maybe a checkbox in your own profile.
As far as I understand, it's a decision that PG made fairly early on. HN allows YC companies to post job openings without comments, flagging, etc...
All other non-YC jobs are quickly sent to the dead bin.
In the cost benefit analysis I think the job postings win hands down. If you want a news aggregator rather than a community site there are several really good ones elsewhere.
A different point put metaphorically is that this comment is like enjoying the snacks and drinks at a party and then vocally complaining that the Russian tea cakes taste like crap. You might be right but maybe the more tactful thing to do is just avoid them.
But you're right: the tactful thing will be to simply remove HN from my RSS reader, if the justin.tv job postings continue to fill it.
Can anyone confirm this?
example.com/flag?article=729801
example.com/item?id=729801&flag=true
example.com/article/729801/flag
etc, etc.
One word: sessions. You can roll out whatever ACL-scheme you want over sessions.
I think comments were disabled because they generally diverged straight into discussion on the nature of the companies in question.
and I think its completely reasonable for yc companies to use their own "forum" to advertise jobs directly to a community that probably has more well suited applicants than any other around. In fact I think its more than reasonable, imo its a healthy and positive thing.