The Bitcoin phenomenon seems to fit the basic definition of a speculative
bubble — that is, a special kind of fad, a mania for holding an asset
in expectation of its appreciation.
Shiller correctly identified the housing bubble long before others did, so he has a lot of credibility here. But doesn't truly disruptive innovation exhibit a similar pattern? Whether it's Google, or Tesla, or Netflix, the "mania" to hold the asset proves to be justified as entire industries are transformed. The central problem with Bitcoin in its present form, though,
is that it doesn’t really solve any sensible economic problem.
The current monetary system is unfree, just like communication systems before the internet were unfree. I cannot transmit value over space and time, across borders, to anyone, for arbitrarily small or large amounts, at nearly zero cost. That seems like a "sensible economic problem" that needs a solution.Despite its flaws, Bitcoin does a pretty good job solving these problems today, and future generations of cryptocurrency will only get better.
I don't argue that cryptocurrencies can or should replace government currencies, but they clearly accomplish something valuable.
After all, if cryptocurrencies had zero utility, why would so much talent be devoted to stealing them?