I Hate Open Floorplans
richardboydsmith.wordpress.com
richardboydsmith.wordpress.com
Only problem was the constant interruptions that would occur. Either by people who were looking for another co-worker who was not at their desk, or the co-workers themselves.
People couldn't understand how I managed to miss calls on the cellphone I put in front of my desk (on silent/non-vibrate). Most of the time it's because I'm so focused on my work I don't notice the black screen change for 10 seconds, or it's simply because I'm in the flow and I can't afford to let it disrupt me. There was one co-worker who would only ever IM me (I don't check IMs until I'm free), and I never realized it until now, but I really appreciate that.
Occasionally working at home only makes it worse. My family still doesn't really have an idea what I do for a job, and to them, interrupting someone typing stuff on a keyboard all day or asking them questions is perfectly normal. I too, seem very detached or out-of-it to people when I'm focused on my work. I've been experimenting with working only in late hours when everyone else is asleep to get an hour of two of pure focus. It's been working amazingly well, but it's definitely more commitment.
Some of the stated reasons for open plans are collaboration, cost savings, sense of team, etc... Whether or not those are valid metrics which are actually improved by open plan layouts is a different question than a single employee's perception of them.
When discussing private or semi-private office plans there are still some important things to consider.
One that would be important to me is access to natural light which is greatly reduced by walls or cubicles. Another that would be important to employers would be the modularity of an office. Fixed walls are a huge nuisance and costly to adjust with any company growth.
I'm not really sure what the solution is, other than maybe "only hire cubicle lovers." You could offer both arrangements and let employees choose, but this probably isn't economically or practically feasible for most companies.
At one former job, they switched the managers from private offices to cubicles. That really made it hard to have a decent technical discussion, squeezed in their cubicle.
Mixing coders (or CAD engineers, or anyone who may need hours of uninterrupted concentration) in with people who are likely to interrupt them is asking for trouble.